Request a bill review
Utility bill audits · Electricity

Electricity bill audits for commercial and industrial companies

Electric bills carry most of a plant's utility cost and most of its billing risk: rate class, demand, meter setup, voltage, seasons, riders and, in competitive markets, capacity tags and supply contracts. We test every input against the tariff and contract that should govern it, for every account in scope, and recover what should not have been billed.

An electricity bill audit is a review of 36 to 48 months of commercial or industrial electric bills against the utility's tariff, the meter setup and, where a supplier is involved, the supply contract. It finds charges that were calculated on the wrong basis, files documented refund claims, and moves each account to the rate it qualifies for.

01 / 08

Why commercial electric bills go wrong without looking wrong

An industrial electric bill is built from a rate class, measured energy and demand, a meter setup, a calendar of seasons and time periods, riders, and in competitive markets, a supplier contract and market charges. Each input can be wrong while the arithmetic stays right, so the bill never looks wrong.

The stakes differ by customer type. The US Energy Information Administration (EIA) reports that in 2025 the average retail price of electricity was 13.41 cents per kWh for commercial customers and 8.62 cents for industrial customers. The EIA explains the gap: industrial customers use more electricity and can take it at higher voltages, which makes them cheaper to serve. So the price a site pays depends on which schedule it sits on and how the utility measures it, not only on how much energy it uses.

About 5 million
US commercial customers estimated to be eligible for tariffs with demand charges above $15 per kW, out of about 18 million in total, in a survey of more than 10,000 tariffs by the National Renewable Energy Laboratory and Clean Energy Group.
$28.92 to $333.44
PJM capacity clearing price per MW-day for the 2024/25 and 2027/28 delivery years (PJM).

A single 15-minute demand interval can cost as much as weeks of steady use, and in some markets a few hours of load on the grid's peak days set a full year of capacity cost. Both rest on measurements the customer rarely sees on the bill.

02 / 08

What we test on every electric account

Every account in scope is tested, not a sample. These are the inputs, what goes wrong with each, and where it matters most.

What we testWhat goes wrongWhere it matters most
Rate classThe account sits on a schedule that no longer matches its demand, load factor or voltage, often since an expansion or acquisition. See rate misclassification.Plants that grew or changed shifts
Demand and ratchetsStuck or misread demand registers, ratchet math applied wrongly, peaks billed above what the schedule permits. A ratchet is a minimum demand charge set by a past peak. See demand charge errors.Demand-heavy sites: metals, refrigeration, compressors
Meter multiplierA wrong multiplier after a meter or transformer exchange inflates every bill in proportion. See meter multiplier errors.Large services with current transformers
Service voltageA site taking service at primary voltage billed as secondary, missing the lower primary rate or discount.Plants that own their transformers
Power factorPower factor charges billed on wrong readings, or penalties that a correction could remove. Power factor measures how efficiently a load uses the current it draws; large motor loads lower it.Motor-heavy loads
Seasons and time periodsSummer rates billed outside the tariff dates; on-peak hours that do not match the schedule. See seasonal rate errors.Seasonal and time-of-use tariffs
Capacity and transmission tagsPJM peak load contributions and transmission tags, or ERCOT 4CP values, set from the wrong intervals. See capacity tag errors.PJM and ERCOT accounts
RidersOptional riders a site could leave, or programs it never joined.Every market
Classification and readsAccounts carrying charges that do not fit how the business operates, and estimated reads never trued up. See corporate classification errors and estimated reads.Sites after an account change or meter problem
Supply contractSupplier prices, pass-throughs and bandwidth terms that do not match the contract.Deregulated markets

Illustrative example, not a client result

A plant's current transformers are replaced during a service upgrade and the correct multiplier changes from 800 to 400, but the billing system keeps 800. Every kWh and every kW is now billed at twice the metered amount, every month, while the bill's arithmetic stays correct. It shows up only when the multiplier on the bill is checked against the meter and transformer records, which is part of every electric audit.

03 / 08

Regulated and deregulated markets

In regulated states the utility bills everything under one tariff, and the rate class carries most of the risk. Those accounts are often the least reviewed, because no supplier competition draws attention to them. In deregulated markets the utility bills delivery, a supplier bills energy, and grid operators set capacity and transmission charges from each site's peaks. An audit tests all three: the delivery tariff, the supplier contract and the market-set tags. See charges by market for how PJM, ERCOT, MISO and other markets bill.

Capacity charges deserve their own check

In PJM, the capacity cost on a bill is the site's peak load contribution (PLC) multiplied by the auction price. PJM's auction reports show the regional clearing price rose from $28.92 per MW-day for 2024/25 to $329.17 for 2026/27 and $333.44 for 2027/28, and the 2028/29 auction cleared at the $325.00 cap. A tag set from the wrong hours, or never updated after a site cut its load, overcharges every month of the delivery year. A fixed-price supply contract does not remove this cost if capacity is passed through. Read PJM capacity prices and industrial budgets and the ERCOT 4CP guide.

Illustrative example, not a client result

A site with a 5 MW capacity tag pays roughly 5 x $329.17, or about $1,646 a day, for capacity in the 2026/27 delivery year: about $600,700 over the year, before scaling factors and any supplier markup. The same tag at the 2024/25 price of $28.92 cost about $52,800 a year. If the tag should have been 4 MW, the overcharge at 2026/27 prices is about $120,000 for the year.

04 / 08

Who an electric audit suits

Organizations with many locations, several utilities, mixed load profiles or recent acquisitions find the most. So do companies whose accounts have never been independently reviewed, including those already working with an energy manager or broker. Electric findings concentrate in a few situations:

05 / 08

How the electric audit runs

The audit is an off-site review of bills, meter data and tariffs. There is no hardware to install, no site visit and no production interruption.

  1. Authorize

    You sign a letter of authorization (LOA) and share one bill per site, or an account list with service addresses. We pull billing history and interval data directly from the utilities.

  2. Test every account

    We review 36 to 48 months of bills for every account in scope against the tariffs in force at the time, the meter setup and the classification, with TaraBase checking the math.

  3. Approve and file

    Initial findings usually arrive in 30 to 60 days and are presented in a meeting. You approve each claim; we file it and handle every utility conversation. Nothing changes on an account without your written approval.

  4. Recover and correct

    Formal refunds or rate changes can take a further 60 to 120 days, depending on the utility and jurisdiction. The recoverable period is typically 1 to 5 years, set by each state and utility; see refund periods by state.

It helps to send supply contracts for accounts in deregulated markets and a note of any site changes in the last five years: expansions, closures, new transformers or meters. One bill is enough to start an assessment; about 12 months of bills shows seasonal patterns.

06 / 08

What you receive

  • A findings report, presented in a meeting, separating one-time refunds, recurring savings and items that need more data.
  • For each claim, the tariff sheet or rule it relies on and the calculation of what should have been billed.
  • Copies of what is filed with the utility, its response, and proof of each refund as it posts.

If every account is already correct, you have documentation that it is, at no cost.

Results on electric accounts

At one of Missouri's largest industrial energy users, a national protein processor, the utility applied its higher summer rate schedule to a billing period that fell entirely in the winter season. Testing further back found the same error a year earlier.

National protein processor$166,957Recovered from a seasonal rate error repeated in two billing periods.
Diversified agribusiness, refunds$117,412Tied to a demand-billing error and a rate-schedule correction at one facility.
Same client, rider correction~$120,000A year from leaving an optional tariff rider that was costing money.

Since 2000, recoveries have most often equaled 3% to 15% of annual utility spend, depending on the utilities involved and the billing history. Results vary and are not guaranteed. Read the protein processor case and the agribusiness case.

07 / 08

How it fits with procurement, bill pay and reporting

The audit can be engaged on its own. An audit is backward-looking and checks whether bills were calculated correctly; energy procurement is forward-looking and sets future supply prices. Auditing first matters, because a wrong rate class or multiplier otherwise becomes part of the baseline used to judge supply bids. See audit vs procurement.

The same account inventory supports utility bill pay, TaraBase reporting including Scope 2 data, and Utility Cost Intelligence. Any supplier commission on procurement is disclosed up front; see independence.

How it is priced

There is no upfront fee. The fee is contingency-based, usually 15% to 50% of refunds and verified savings, paid only when you receive them. Utilities never pay us. Start with a free rate class check or a 15-account pilot audit. See pricing.

08 / 08

Questions buyers ask

What does an electric bill audit check?

Rate class, demand and ratchets, meter multipliers, service voltage, power factor, seasonal and time-of-use periods, riders, classification and estimated reads, capacity and transmission tags, and the supply contract in deregulated markets.

Do you audit electric bills in regulated states?

Yes. Rate misclassification and billing-rule errors exist in every market, and regulated-state accounts are often the least reviewed.

Can you check our PJM capacity tag?

Yes. We compare the peak load contribution and transmission tags on the bill with the utility's published peak hours and your interval data. With PJM capacity prices above $300 per MW-day since the 2026/27 delivery year, a wrong tag is expensive.

How far back do electric audits go?

We review 36 to 48 months of bills. How far back refunds can go depends on the state and the utility, typically 1 to 5 years; see refund periods by state.

Do you need to visit our plants or install meters?

No. The audit works from bills, meter and interval data, and tariffs obtained under a letter of authorization. Nothing is installed and operations are not interrupted.

Our energy manager already reviews our bills. Is an audit still useful?

Often, yes. Energy managers usually focus on usage and supply. At a national steel company with an energy manager in place, an independent audit still found 17 misclassified accounts and $374,326 in refunds. See second-opinion audits.

Sources

  1. US EIA, Electricity explained: prices and factors affecting prices, 2025 average retail prices (commercial 13.41¢, industrial 8.62¢ per kWh) and why industrial customers served at higher voltage cost less to supply.
  2. NREL and Clean Energy Group, Identifying Potential Markets for Behind-the-Meter Battery Energy Storage: A Survey of U.S. Demand Charges (2017), nearly 5 million of about 18 million US commercial customers eligible for tariffs with demand charges above $15 per kW.
  3. Clean Energy Group, Millions of Commercial Customers Could Cut Costs with Battery Storage (2017), the analysis compared load profiles against more than 10,000 utility tariffs.
  4. PJM, 2028/2029 Base Residual Auction Report, RTO capacity clearing prices of $28.92 (2024/25), $329.17 (2026/27), $333.44 (2027/28) and $325.00 (2028/29) per MW-day.

Find out what your bills should have cost.

Send one recent bill per site, or a list of accounts. We tell you where we expect findings before you sign anything. No upfront audit fee.