Utility bill audits for steel and metals companies
Melting, reheating, galvanizing and heat treating make electricity demand and natural gas the largest utility costs in metals. Most of the money sits at the big mills, but most of the billing errors we find sit at the smaller plants, where accounts are left on general-service schedules for years. We audit electricity and natural gas bills for metals companies across the US and Canada, off-site and on contingency.
01 / 07
Why utility costs matter in steel and metals
The US produced 81 million metric tons of raw steel in 2024, according to the US Geological Survey (USGS), and 72% of it came from electric arc furnaces (EAFs). That production is spread across 104 minimills run by 49 companies, plus two integrated producers. Around the mills sit foundries, galvanizers, coaters, processors and fabrication shops, each with a different load profile.
- $16.5 billion
- Spent on purchased energy by US primary metals plants in 2022 (EIA, Manufacturing Energy Consumption Survey).
- $3.3 billion and $2.5 billion
- Purchased electricity ($3,295 million) and natural gas ($2,520 million) at US iron and steel mills and ferroalloy plants in 2022.
- 72%
- Share of natural gas in primary metals used for process heating in 2022: reheat, annealing, ladle preheat and similar furnaces (436 of 603 billion cubic feet).
- $4.3 billion
- Purchased electricity at US fabricated metal products plants in 2022, plus $1.9 billion of natural gas.
Each part of the industry is billed differently:
- EAF mills and melt shops draw very large, fast-changing electric loads. They usually take service at primary or transmission voltage, often under special contracts, interruptible riders or real-time pricing, where demand, ratchets and power factor drive the bill.
- Foundries combine electric melting, often induction furnaces, with gas-fired heat treating and core ovens. US foundries spent $853 million on purchased electricity and $282 million on natural gas in 2022.
- Galvanizing and metal coating plants are gas-heavy. Zinc kettles are typically held at temperature around the clock, and pre-treatment and drying add more gas load, so the gas service schedule is often the biggest lever on the bill.
- Fabrication shops and service centers run welding, cutting, compressed air and paint cure ovens. They are smaller and more numerous, and are the sites most often left on general-service schedules.
02 / 07
How metals plants are billed
Large metals loads touch almost every complex part of an industrial tariff.
Electricity
- Demand charges and ratchets. Demand is the highest average load in a short interval, often 15 or 30 minutes. A demand ratchet is a minimum demand charge set by a past peak, so one melt-shop start-up or test can set billing demand for up to a year.
- Voltage level. Plants that own their substation and take service at primary or transmission voltage usually pay lower delivery rates than secondary-voltage customers. The bill has to reflect the voltage and metering point actually in place.
- Interruptible and curtailable riders. Many mills accept curtailment in return for lower rates or credits. Credits, penalties and notice terms all have to be billed as the rider says.
- Power factor. Furnaces and large motors lower power factor. Some tariffs add a charge or raise billed demand when power factor falls below a set threshold.
- Coincident peak charges. In some markets, a plant's load during a few system peak hours sets a full year of transmission or capacity cost, as with the ERCOT 4CP charge in Texas.
Natural gas
- Large-volume and transportation service. Plants above a usage threshold can move from a general-service schedule to a large-volume or transportation schedule, often at a much lower delivery cost per unit. Some plants qualify and are never moved.
- Firm and interruptible gas. Interruptible gas costs less but can be curtailed in cold weather. Plants need to know which service they are on and whether it is billed correctly.
- Balancing and capacity charges. Transportation customers can be billed for imbalances, contract demand and daily capacity, set by terms that change with usage. See our gas capacity ratings guide.
03 / 07
Where metals companies overpay
In a national metals network, each plant's error tends to look small. Added together across plants and years, they often reach six figures.
Gas on a general-service schedule
Galvanizing, coating and heat treating plants that use enough gas for a large-volume schedule but are still billed as small commercial accounts. See rate misclassification.
Electric rate class that no longer fits
A plant that added a line, a furnace or a shift may qualify for a large-power or high-load-factor schedule it was never moved to.
Ratchets after outages and start-ups
Billed demand set by a one-time peak, ratchets calculated from the wrong month, or ratchets still running after a furnace was removed. See demand charge errors.
Meter multiplier errors
Substation, transformer and meter changes for new equipment can change the multiplier without the bill following. See meter multiplier errors.
Interruptible credits missing
Curtailment credits not applied, or penalties billed for events the plant met.
Wrong voltage or loss adjustment
Primary-voltage service billed at secondary rates, or transformer loss adjustments applied when the plant owns the transformer.
Seasonal rate errors
Summer pricing billed weeks early or late. See seasonal rate errors.
Closed and consolidated sites
Plants shut or merged after an acquisition that still carry minimum bills and customer charges. See closed-site accounts.
04 / 07
What we have found in steel and metals
A national steel company already had an energy manager in place. Our independent audit found 17 misclassified accounts in 7 states, billed on schedules the accounts did not belong on. One natural gas account in San Antonio, Texas was billed on Schedule G when it qualified for large-volume Schedule LVG. Moving it saves $33,554 a year on that account.
| Metal coating and galvanizing, 60 locations, total documented savings | $421,845 |
Read the steel company case study. Across all clients since 2000, recoveries have most often equaled 3% to 15% of annual utility spend, depending on the utilities and the billing history.
05 / 07
How an audit works for a metals company
Everything is done off-site from bills, meter data and tariffs. There is no site visit, no equipment to install and no interruption to melt, coating or finishing lines.
Send the account list
One recent bill per plant, or a list of electric and gas accounts. You sign a letter of authorization (LOA) so we can request history and meter data from each utility.
We review 36 to 48 months
Each account is checked against the tariffs and riders in force for each billing period: rate class, demand, ratchets, voltage, gas schedule, credits and riders.
You see the findings
First findings usually come in 30 to 60 days, with the tariff language and bill lines behind each one. No account is changed without your written approval.
Refunds and corrections
We file claims and move accounts to the correct schedules. Refunds usually arrive a further 60 to 120 days later. The recoverable period is set by each state and utility, typically 1 to 5 years.
Useful to have ready
A list of plants by process (melt shop, foundry, galvanizing, coating, fabrication), any interruptible or special contracts, gas transportation agreements, recent substation or meter changes, and plants closed or acquired in the last five years.
The fee is contingent, usually 15% to 50% of refunds and verified savings, paid only when you receive them. A 15-account pilot or a free rate class check is a low-risk way to start.
06 / 07
After the audit
Once every plant is on the right schedule, the same account inventory supports the next steps. Each is optional; the audit can be engaged on its own.
- Energy procurement for electricity and gas in deregulated markets, priced on corrected loads and schedules. Any supplier commission is disclosed up front. Our natural gas price page tracks the market.
- Utility bill pay across all plants, with a 30 to 45 day transition. Water and sewer bills can be included in bill pay.
- TaraBase reporting on savings, usage and contracts, with Scope 2 data taken from the bills.
- Utility Cost Intelligence to catch new errors as plants add furnaces, lines or shifts.
07 / 07
Questions buyers ask
Fees, results, and how an audit fits beside the broker or energy manager you already have.
Which metals plants have the most billing errors?
Often the smaller ones. Large mills get close attention from energy staff and utilities. Smaller plants, coating lines and fabrication shops are more likely to sit on general-service schedules they have outgrown.
Can a galvanizing plant be on the wrong gas schedule?
Yes. Plants with steady, high gas use may qualify for a large-volume or transportation schedule. At one steel company account, moving from Schedule G to Schedule LVG saves $33,554 a year. Only the utility's tariff decides eligibility.
We have an energy manager. Why use an outside audit?
An independent audit is a second check on billing, not a replacement for energy management. At a national steel company with an energy manager, it found 17 misclassified accounts in 7 states.
Will the audit affect production?
No. It works from bills, meter data and tariffs. Nobody visits the plant and nothing is installed.
How far back can we recover overcharges?
Typically 1 to 5 years, set by each state and utility. Recent errors are worth finding quickly because older months can age out.
How is the fee set?
On contingency: usually 15% to 50% of refunds and verified savings, paid only when you receive them. Utilities never pay us. See pricing.
Sources
- US Geological Survey, Mineral Commodity Summaries 2025: Iron and Steel, 81 million metric tons of raw steel in 2024, 72% from electric arc furnaces, 49 companies at 104 minimills, two integrated producers.
- US EIA, 2022 Manufacturing Energy Consumption Survey results, $16.5 billion purchased energy spend in primary metals.
- US EIA, MECS 2022 Table 7.10, expenditures for purchased electricity, natural gas and steam, electricity and gas spend for iron and steel mills, foundries and fabricated metal products.
- US EIA, MECS 2022 Table 5.1, end uses of fuel consumption, process heating share (436 of 603 billion cubic feet) of primary metals natural gas.
Find out what your bills should have cost.
Send one recent bill per site, or a list of accounts. We tell you where we expect findings before you sign anything. No upfront audit fee.