Request a bill review
Discovery Energy ยท Billing Error Library

Seasonal rate errors

A seasonal rate error is the application of seasonal pricing, usually higher summer rates, to service dates outside the season the tariff defines. The math on the bill is correct; only the rate is wrong for those dates.

This page explains how tariffs define seasons, how billing periods that cross a season boundary should be billed, why the error recurs, how to test your own bills, and what a real correction looked like at a Missouri protein plant.

01 / 07

How seasonal rates work

Many electric and gas tariffs price the same service differently by season. Summer-peaking electric utilities charge more for energy or demand in summer; gas utilities often charge more for winter capacity. The season dates are written into the tariff, and they are defined in one of two ways.

  • By calendar dates. The Empire District Electric Company (Liberty) in Missouri defines the Summer Season in its optional time-of-use rider as June 1 through September 30, and the Winter Season as October 1 through May 31.
  • By billing months. Georgia Power's Power and Light Large schedule applies its summer rules to "the billing months of June through September." CPS Energy's Large Volume Gas rate prices billing demand at one rate for winter billing (December through March) and a lower rate for non-winter billing (April through November).

Seasons reach beyond the energy price. Georgia Power's schedule sets billing demand in every month from 95% of the highest summer peak or 60% of the highest winter peak, so a month assigned to the wrong season can change a ratchet for the following year. CPS Energy's LVG sets April through November billing demand from the previous winter's peak. Time-of-use schedules often change their on-peak hours by season as well.

When a billing period crosses the season boundary

Meter reads rarely fall on the first of the month, so most years at least one bill straddles each changeover. Tariffs and billing systems handle this in different ways:

  • Proration by days. Usage is split by the number of days on each side of the change and each part is billed at its season's rate.
  • The whole bill at one season. The season is set by the read date, the bill date or the billing month, and the entire period is billed at that season's rate.

A 2018 filing by Otter Tail Power Company with the South Dakota Public Utilities Commission shows the difference. For a bill read on September 10 and October 10, with 600 kWh and a seasonal change on October 1, its old billing system billed the entire month on the winter rate because the bill date fell in winter. Its new system would bill 400 kWh at the summer rate and 200 kWh at the winter rate. Both followed rules the utility had filed. The point for an auditor is that the method is a tariff and system choice, and the bill must follow whichever method the tariff in force actually requires.

02 / 07

How seasonal errors happen

  • The switch is triggered early. The billing system changes season on a read date or cycle date rather than the tariff date, so a spring period is billed entirely at summer rates.
  • Proration is skipped. A period that crosses the boundary is billed at one season's rate when the tariff requires a split, or split when it requires one rate.
  • Season dates change and the system does not. A rate case or tariff revision moves the season dates or changes billing-month definitions, and some accounts or schedules keep the old ones.
  • Read cycles shift. A meter moves to a new read route, or a read is late or estimated, and a period that used to end before the changeover now runs past it.
  • Manual rebills. A corrected or cancelled-and-rebilled period is recalculated with the wrong season.
  • Seasonal demand rules misapplied. A ratchet or winter demand is calculated from months assigned to the wrong season.

Because these are configuration errors, they repeat. If a system applied summer rates early one May, it may do the same the next May, on the same account and on sister accounts.

How it shows up on a bill

The invoice is arithmetically correct. The clue is the price: a summer unit rate, a summer demand charge or a summer rate code on a bill whose service dates sit entirely, or mostly, outside summer. Year-over-year comparisons can hide it, since the same error in the prior year makes the bills look consistent.

Illustrative example, not a client result

A tariff's summer season starts June 1 and requires proration by days. A plant's bill runs from May 15 to June 14, 31 days, with 620,000 kWh. Correctly billed, 17 days (340,000 kWh) are winter and 14 days (280,000 kWh) are summer. If the system bills the whole period at summer rates and the summer energy price is 1.5 cents per kWh higher, the overcharge is 340,000 times $0.015, or $5,100, on one bill for one meter. The same error at the autumn changeover, and in each prior year, multiplies it.

03 / 07

Who is most exposed

  • Large, continuous loads. Facilities that run around the clock, such as food and protein processing, cold storage and heavy manufacturing, use enough in a single billing period that a few weeks at the wrong rate becomes a large number.
  • Accounts with many meters. A seasonal setting applied to an account can be wrong on every meter at once.
  • Seasonal operations. Grain and oilseed sites whose peak use falls near a season boundary.
  • Multi-utility portfolios. Each utility defines its seasons differently, and the definitions change over time.

04 / 07

How to test for it

Find the season definition in the tariff

Read the rate schedule and any rider for the seasonal effective dates (for example, June 1 to September 30), and note whether they are calendar dates or billing months.

Find the proration rule

Check the schedule and the utility's general rules for how a period that crosses a season change is billed.

List the service dates around each changeover

For every meter, list the start and end dates of each billing period near the spring and autumn changes.

Check the rate applied to each portion

Compare the unit rates and demand rates on each bill with the tariff's seasonal prices for those dates.

Check seasonal demand and ratchets

Confirm ratchets, winter demand and time-of-use hours used the correct season's months.

Repeat for every year

Repeat for every prior year in the recoverable window. Errors in recurring processes recur.

Recheck after any change

Test again after a rate case, a tariff revision, a change of read route or a utility billing system change.

05 / 07

How it is corrected, and how far back refunds go

A seasonal claim is usually straightforward to prove, because the evidence is documentary: the tariff's effective date, the actual service dates billed, and the difference between the rates applied and the rates owed. The utility rebills the affected periods, as a bill credit or a refund.

The period that can be recovered depends on the state and the utility's tariff, typically 1 to 5 years. Because the error is tied to specific, datable billing periods, it often fits rules that refund from the date an error began. See how far back utilities refund overcharges, by state, and overcharge recovery.

06 / 07

A real example: a Missouri protein plant

A national protein processing company, one of the largest energy users in Missouri, asked Discovery to verify whether Evergy had billed its 800,000-square-foot facility correctly. The company's controller had already reviewed the accounts and found nothing conclusive. Discovery audited three years of billing history across every meter on the account and mapped each invoice's service period against the Missouri West summer and winter schedules.

The service period of April 28 to May 27, 2020, was billed entirely under the summer rate schedule, about five weeks before its June 1 effective date; the period ended four days before summer rates should have applied at all. Discovery documented the tariff date, the service dates and the overcharge and presented them to Evergy. Extending the same test back a year found an identical error in the May 2019 billing period.

2020 billing period$108,739Bill credit for April 28 to May 27, 2020.
2019 billing period$58,218Refund for the identical error in May 2019.
Total verified recovery$166,957One-time historical corrections, not recurring savings.

The same error on the same account two years apart points to how the schedule was applied, not a one-off clerical mistake. Read the protein processing case.

07 / 07

Questions buyers ask

How do seasonal rate errors happen?

Billing periods rarely align with calendar months. When a period straddles the seasonal start date, the system may apply the new season's rate to the whole period, or switch early. Season dates that change in a rate case and are not updated cause the same result.

Would an accounting review catch it?

Rarely. The invoice is arithmetically correct. Catching it requires comparing each period's service dates with the tariff's seasonal effective dates. At the Missouri protein plant, a controller's review had not surfaced it.

Is every bill that crosses June 1 billed wrongly?

No. Some tariffs prorate by days, and some legitimately bill the whole period at one season based on the billing month or read date. The test is whether the bill follows the method the tariff in force requires.

Do seasonal errors affect natural gas bills?

They can. Gas schedules may price winter and non-winter demand or capacity differently, and some set off-season billing demand from the previous winter's peak. The same date tests apply.

How far back should we check?

Every changeover in the recoverable window, which is typically 1 to 5 years depending on the state and utility. Discovery reviews 36 to 48 months of bills, which covers three or four spring and autumn changeovers on each meter.

Is a seasonal correction recurring savings?

Mostly not. It is a one-time historical correction for the periods billed wrongly. Once the utility fixes the configuration, future bills follow the tariff calendar, which prevents the error from repeating.

Sources

  1. The Empire District Electric Company d.b.a. Liberty, Optional Time of Use Adjustment Rider OTOU (Missouri), Summer Season June 1 through September 30 and Winter Season October 1 through May 31.
  2. Georgia Power, Power and Light Large Schedule PLL-18, summer defined as the billing months of June through September and seasonal 95% and 60% ratchets.
  3. CPS Energy, Large Volume Gas Rate LVG, winter (December through March) and non-winter (April through November) billing demand rules.
  4. Otter Tail Power Company, Petition to the South Dakota Public Utilities Commission, Docket EL18-031 (2018), seasonal proration example and the prior practice of billing the whole period at the bill-date season.

Find out what your bills should have cost.

Send one recent bill per site, or a list of accounts. We tell you where we expect findings before you sign anything. No upfront audit fee.