Request a bill review
Discovery Energy · Services

Utility bill audits for commercial and industrial companies

We test every electric and natural gas account you have against the tariff that should govern it, recover what the utility overcharged, and move each account to the rate it qualifies for. You pay nothing unless money comes back or your bills go down.

A utility bill audit is an independent review of historical utility invoices against the utility's published tariffs, rate classes, meter configuration and state billing rules, to find overcharges, recover refunds and lower future bills. Discovery Energy performs commercial utility bill audits on contingency for multi-site commercial and industrial organizations in the US and Canada, and has done so since 2000.

01 / 10

What recent utility bill audits recovered

Four documented engagements, each with the error that caused the overcharge. Refunds are one-time recoveries of past overbilling; ongoing savings are lower bills after the correction.

Results from Discovery Energy utility bill audits
ClientWhat was wrongRefundsOngoing savings
Multi-state RNG producerAccounts set up wrong as sites were added across 10 states; transport gas not set up at 13 sites$3,959,202$404,000+ a month, with procurement
National steel company17 misclassified accounts, missed by the incumbent energy manager$374,326$150,000+ a year
Protein processing plantSeasonal rate applied before the dates the tariff allows$166,957Correct seasonal billing going forward
Diversified agribusinessRate, rider and metering errors$117,412About $120,000 a year

Figures are from the published case studies. All case studies.

02 / 10

What a commercial utility bill audit tests on every account

Most billing errors are not arithmetic mistakes. The math on the bill is right, but the basis it starts from, such as the rate class or the meter multiplier, is wrong. These are the checks we run on every account in scope, not a sample.

Checks run on every account
CheckWhat goes wrongTypical result
Rate classThe account sits on a schedule that no longer matches its load, often since a plant expansion or acquisition.Refund plus a lower rate every month
Tariff dates and seasonsSummer or winter rates applied outside the dates the tariff allows.One-time credit or refund
Meter multiplierA wrong multiplier, often after a meter exchange, inflates every bill in proportion.Refund for the affected period
Demand and ratchetsStuck or misread demand, wrong ratchet math, peaks above what the schedule permits.Refund and corrected demand billing
Corporate classificationAccounts carrying charges that do not fit how the business actually operates, often after an account change.Refund plus lower bills
Riders and optional programsCharges for riders a site can opt out of, or incentives it never enrolled in.Recurring savings
Reads and true-upsEstimated reads never reconciled, overlapping periods, duplicate charges.Credits for the duplicated amounts

The billing error library explains each error, how to spot it on a bill and how a refund is claimed.

03 / 10

Electricity and natural gas bill audits, in depth

The checks above apply to every account. Where the money hides depends on the fuel.

Electricity bills

Most of a plant's utility cost, and most of its billing risk, sits on the electric bill: rate class, demand and ratchets, meter multipliers, service voltage and power factor, and in PJM and ERCOT, capacity and transmission tags set from each site's peaks.

Go deeper: electricity bill audits

Natural gas bills

Gas bills turn metered volume into billed energy with heat-content and pressure factors, then apply a rate class and a delivery service. Sales or transport service, firm or interruptible, and large-volume schedules are where gas-intensive plants most often overpay. A natural gas bill audit checks each of those inputs against the tariff.

Go deeper: natural gas bill audits

Each guide walks through every input we test on that fuel, what goes wrong and what it has been worth to clients.

How a utility bill audit works, step by step

  1. Authorize

    You sign a letter of authorization and share one recent bill per site, or an account list with service addresses. We pull 36 to 48 months of billing history and interval data directly from the utilities.

  2. Test every account

    Not a sample. Each account is tested against its tariff, meter setup and classification, with TaraBase checking the math.

  3. Review findings and approve

    We present the findings in a meeting, separating one-time refunds, recurring savings and items that need more data. You approve every claim and account change before anything is filed.

  4. File and handle the utility

    We file each claim with the tariff sheet, rule or program it relies on and handle every conversation with the utility. Service is never interrupted.

  5. Recover and correct

    Refunds arrive as credits or checks and accounts move to the right rate. Savings are measured against a baseline agreed before work starts, and later bills are checked to confirm each correction held.

Initial findings and simple claims usually arrive in 30 to 60 days. Formal regulatory refunds or rate changes can take a further 60 to 120 days, depending on the utility and jurisdiction. How a refund claim is built, filed and paid.

04 / 10

How far back a utility bill audit can recover

A historical utility bill audit reaches back as far as the state and the utility allow refunds, typically 1 to 5 years. Some frameworks allow longer periods when the utility caused the error. We pursue the maximum allowed in each jurisdiction, which is why we review 36 to 48 months of history rather than only the latest bills.

The limit differs by state and sometimes by utility. Utility refund periods by state lists the rule for each one.

05 / 10

What a utility bill audit costs

Nothing upfront. Discovery Energy works on contingency: we are paid 15% to 50% of refunds and verified savings, only after you receive them. If every account is already billed correctly, the audit costs nothing and you keep the documentation that it is.

To test the fit first, start with a 15-account pilot audit: pick 15 representative accounts, including your most complex tariffs, and judge the findings before committing the whole portfolio.

Pricing · Contingency vs fixed-fee utility audits · How we are paid and stay independent

06 / 10

How to compare utility bill audit companies

Utility bill audit companies differ less in what they promise than in how they work. Five questions separate them:

  • Scope: does the firm test every account, or a sample of the largest ones?
  • Look-back: how many months of history does it review, and does it pursue the maximum refund period in each state?
  • Fee basis: what percentage does it take, of what, and for how long?
  • Documented results: can it show named outcomes, with the errors behind them?
  • Working with your team: will it audit alongside your energy manager or broker, or only replace them?

A second opinion is worth having even when an audit is already in someone's scope. At a national steel company, auditing was in scope with the incumbent provider; our independent review still found 17 misclassified accounts and $374,326 in refunds.

Utility bill audit firms compared · How to choose a utility bill auditor · Utility bill audit RFP checklist · Second-opinion audits

07 / 10

What you receive

  • A findings report, presented in a meeting, separating one-time refunds, recurring savings and items needing more data.
  • For each claim, the tariff sheet, rule or program it relies on and the calculation of what should have been billed.
  • Copies of what is filed with the utility, and its response.
  • Proof of each refund or credit as it posts, and confirmation on later bills that the correction held.
  • Savings measured against a baseline agreed before work starts.

Scope

Commodities audited: electricity and natural gas. Water, sewer and other utility bills can be included in bill pay.

Markets: regulated and deregulated, across the US and Canada.

Accounts: every account in scope, not a sample.

Engagement: audit-only, or alongside procurement and bill pay. How we stay independent.

08 / 10

Three possible outcomes, all useful

Refunds

When the utility billed incorrectly in the past, we file documented claims for the recoverable period and manage them through to a credit or check.

Ongoing savings

Rate reclassifications, rider opt-outs and corrected classifications lower every future bill. These usually outlast the refund in value.

Confirmation

If every account is already correct, you have documentation that it is, at no cost. That is worth having before a contract renewal, an acquisition or a budget cycle.

Each claim cites the tariff sheet, rule or program it relies on and is reviewed before it is filed. You approve every one.

09 / 10

Who benefits most

Organizations with many locations, several utilities, mixed load profiles or recent acquisitions find the most. So do companies whose accounts have never been independently reviewed, including those already working with an energy manager or broker.

Past clients range from regional credit unions to global manufacturers, with results from hundreds of thousands of dollars in refunds to multi-million-dollar savings over several years. See utility bill audits for manufacturers and the other industries in the Industries menu.

10 / 10

Questions buyers ask

What does a utility bill audit examine?

Every element of the electric and natural gas bill: rate classification, tariff application, meter readings and multipliers, demand charges, riders, corporate classification, and the state rules that govern how the utility must bill. We review 36 to 48 months of history and compare it with the tariffs as written.

How much does a utility bill audit cost?

Nothing upfront. Discovery Energy is paid 15% to 50% of refunds and verified savings, only after you receive them. If the audit finds nothing, you owe nothing.

How is a utility bill audit different from an energy audit?

An energy audit inspects buildings and equipment to cut how much energy you use. A utility bill audit checks whether you were billed correctly for the energy you did use, recovers overcharges and moves accounts to the right rate. No site visit is needed.

How common are billing errors?

More common than most finance teams expect. Many errors are not arithmetic mistakes; the math is right but the basis, such as the rate class or multiplier, is wrong.

How far back can refunds go?

The recoverable period is typically 1 to 5 years, set by each state and utility. Some frameworks allow longer periods when the utility caused the error. We pursue the maximum allowed in each jurisdiction.

Do you audit natural gas bills as well as electricity?

Yes. Every audit covers both electric and natural gas accounts. Gas bills have their own failure points, such as heat-content and pressure factors, sales versus transport service, and large-volume schedules.

Do you audit in regulated states or only deregulated markets?

Both. Rate misclassification, billing-rule violations and corporate classification errors exist in every market. Regulated-state accounts are often the least reviewed because no supplier competition draws attention to them.

Will an audit affect our relationship with the utility?

No. A billing review is a routine inquiry that utilities handle every day. Service is never interrupted, and you approve every claim and account change before it is filed.

What do you need from us to start?

A signed letter of authorization and one recent bill per site, or an account list with service addresses. One bill is enough to start an assessment; about 12 months of bills shows seasonal patterns.

Can we start with a pilot?

Yes. Discovery offers a 15-account pilot audit: pick 15 representative accounts, including your most complex tariffs, and judge the findings before committing the whole portfolio.

How long does an audit take?

Initial findings and simple claims usually arrive in 30 to 60 days. Formal regulatory refunds or rate changes can take a further 60 to 120 days, depending on the utility and jurisdiction.

Our energy manager says they already audit our bills. Should we still engage Discovery?

That was the situation at a national steel company. Auditing was in scope with its incumbent provider; our independent review still found 17 misclassified accounts and $374,326 in refunds. See second-opinion audits.

Find out what your bills should have cost.

Send one recent bill per site, or a list of accounts. We tell you where we expect findings before you sign anything. No upfront audit fee.