Case studies
Each case names the error, the amount, and whether it was a one-time refund or a saving that repeats. Client names are withheld unless the client has agreed otherwise.
01 / 05
Six documented engagements
These write-ups cover electricity and natural gas audits, procurement and bill pay for multi-site commercial and industrial companies: what was wrong, how it was found and what it was worth. Start with the case closest to your industry, then use the tables below to find others with the same kind of error.
02 / 05
Browse by industry
| Industry | Case | States or footprint | Industry guide |
|---|---|---|---|
| Steel and industrial manufacturing | National steel company | IN, MA, NE, MN, CO, TX, MO | Steel and metals |
| Food and protein processing | Protein processing plant | Missouri, one 800,000 sq ft facility | Food processing |
| Agribusiness | Diversified agribusiness | KS, NE, NC | Agribusiness |
| Renewable natural gas | RNG producer | At least 12 states; refunds in 10 | RNG producers |
| Chemical distribution | Global chemical distributor | 45 states and 7 provinces | Chemical distribution |
| Industrial services | Industrial services provider | 103 facilities across North America | Multi-site energy management |
Browse by error or situation
| Error or situation | Where it appears |
|---|---|
| Wrong rate class | Steel (17 accounts; gas Schedule G to LVG), agribusiness (Kansas LS to SS, Nebraska GSDM to GS), RNG producer |
| Seasonal rate applied early | Protein processing plant (2019 and 2020) |
| Stuck or wrong demand reading | Agribusiness (billed demand stuck at 1,000 kW, then 1,673 kW) |
| Optional rider that could be dropped | Agribusiness (rider opt-out, about 6 mils per kWh) |
| Gas service setup | RNG producer (transport gas at 13 sites), steel (gas Schedule G to LVG) |
| Supply procurement | RNG producer (competitive RFP), industrial services provider (sites outside the broker's two states) |
| Late fees and bill pay | Industrial services provider, chemical distributor |
| After an acquisition | Agribusiness, industrial services provider, chemical distributor |
| Behind an existing provider or internal review | Steel (energy manager), industrial services provider (auditor, broker, bill-pay vendor), protein plant (controller's review) |
| Emissions and ESG reporting | Chemical distributor |
03 / 05
Savings by client
| Client type | Locations | Savings |
|---|---|---|
| Industrial equipment and precision medical | 56 | $1,778,902 |
| Chemical and ingredients distribution | 180 | $1,461,071 |
| Specialty chemical supplier | 28 | $1,375,324 |
| Specialty chemical additives | Not stated | $1,169,175 |
| Logistics and industrial solutions | 200 | $772,968 |
| Metal coating and galvanizing | 60 | $421,845 |
04 / 05
What the numbers mean
- One-time refund
- Money returned for past overbilling, as a check or a bill credit. It is paid once and does not repeat.
- Recurring savings
- Lower bills going forward, from a corrected rate class, a dropped rider or a better supply contract. Shown per month or per year.
- Expected or average
- Some figures are forecasts or averages and are labeled that way, such as the RNG producer's expected $50,000+ a month from transport gas corrections.
- Percentages only
- Where the source data gave a rate reduction but no dollar figure, the case reports the percentage, such as the 38% and 31% average reductions at two agribusiness facilities.
- Savings by client
- The ledger above reports one total of documented savings per client, without separate write-ups.
Each case keeps refunds and recurring savings as separate figures, because they behave differently on a P&L. Annual figures built from monthly savings, such as the RNG producer's "about $4.8 million a year", assume those savings continue. Across audits since 2000, recoveries have most often equaled 3% to 15% of annual utility spend; results depend on the utilities and billing history and are not guaranteed.
Where to start
- You already have an energy manager or broker: the national steel company, then second-opinion audits.
- You just made an acquisition: the diversified agribusiness and utility costs in acquisitions.
- You have one large plant: the protein processing plant.
- You have hundreds of sites and no single view: the chemical distributor and the 103-facility provider.
- You are growing fast across many states: the RNG producer.
05 / 05
Questions buyers ask
Why are client names withheld?
To protect client confidentiality. Names are withheld unless the client has agreed otherwise. The cases still give exact amounts, states, utilities and the errors behind them, with account details redacted from exhibits.
Are these results typical?
They show different types of issues and do not predict the outcome of any other review. Recoveries have most often equaled 3% to 15% of annual utility spend, depending on the utilities and billing history.
What is the difference between a refund and recurring savings?
A refund returns money overbilled in the past and is paid once. Recurring savings come from fixing how an account is set up or priced, so costs stay lower every month going forward.
Find out what your bills should have cost.
Send one recent bill per site, or a list of accounts. We tell you where we expect findings before you sign anything. No upfront audit fee.