Request a bill review
Discovery Energy ยท Industries

Utility bill audits for manufacturers

A plant's utility bill is built from demand readings, ratchets, voltage levels, gas service terms and account classification, and each one can be set up wrong and left that way for years. We audit electricity and natural gas bills for multi-plant manufacturers across the US and Canada, off-site and on contingency, and recover what the tariffs say should not have been billed.

01 / 07

Why utility costs matter in manufacturing

Manufacturing is one of the largest energy buyers in North America. The industrial sector used 33% of all US energy in 2025, according to the US Energy Information Administration (EIA). The EIA's 2022 Manufacturing Energy Consumption Survey (MECS) shows how that turns into cost on the plant floor.

$191.7 billion
Spent by US manufacturers on purchased energy in 2022. Electricity was 36% of that spend and natural gas 26%.
About half
Share of manufacturing electricity used for machine drive: motors, pumps, fans, compressors and conveyors (396,282 of 783,620 million kWh).
94%
Share of manufacturing natural gas that could not be replaced with another fuel in 2022, mostly because the equipment could not burn anything else.
8%
Share of manufacturing establishments with any submetering in 2022. For most plants, the utility meter and the bill are the only record of use.

Three things make plant bills hard to check. Plants are billed on demand as well as energy, so one 15-minute peak can cost as much as weeks of steady use. Their loads change: a new line, a second shift or an idled building moves a plant across tariff thresholds, but the account does not move with it unless someone asks. And a multi-plant manufacturer can have dozens of utilities, each with its own rate book, riders and seasonal rules, so no one person at headquarters knows every tariff.

Gas adds a second layer. The MECS shows that 78% of manufacturers' 2022 spend on purchased natural gas went to nonutility suppliers, so most plants receive a utility delivery bill and a separate supply invoice that both have to be correct.

02 / 07

How manufacturing plants are billed

Industrial tariffs differ by utility and state, but most plant bills are built from the same parts.

Tariff featureWhat it meansWhere it goes wrong
Demand chargeA charge per kW on the highest average load in a short interval, often 15 or 30 minutes, during the billing period.Stuck or misread demand registers, wrong interval, start-up spikes billed as normal load.
Demand ratchetA minimum demand charge set by a past peak, usually a percentage of the highest demand in the prior 11 or 12 months.Ratchet calculated from the wrong month or percentage, or kept running after equipment was removed.
Rate class or scheduleThe tariff an account is assigned to, based on size, load factor, voltage or use.Plant grew, shrank or changed shifts and still sits on the schedule it had years ago.
Service voltagePlants that own transformers and take service at primary or transmission voltage often qualify for lower rates.Account billed at secondary voltage, or loss adjustments applied twice.
Power factorSome tariffs adjust billed demand or add a charge when power factor falls below a set threshold. Large motor loads lower power factor.Adjustment applied after capacitors were installed, or based on a faulty reading.
Interruptible or curtailable serviceA lower rate or credit in return for cutting load when the utility calls.Credits missing, or a plant that stopped participating still billed under the rider's terms.
Gas transportation and large-volume schedulesLarge gas users can buy supply from a marketer and pay the utility only for delivery, often on a large-volume or interruptible schedule.Plant left on a general-service gas schedule, or balancing and capacity charges billed incorrectly.
RidersRiders for fuel, transmission, efficiency programs and other costs.Riders the plant has opted out of, or no longer qualifies for, still billed.

Illustrative example, not a client result

A plant normally peaks at 3,000 kW. A start-up test after a July shutdown briefly reaches 5,000 kW. Under a tariff with an 80% ratchet, billed demand cannot fall below 4,000 kW for the next 11 months, even though the plant never again draws more than 3,000 kW. If the ratchet is applied correctly, the cost is avoidable only by managing the start-up. If the utility used the wrong percentage or the wrong month, the overcharge is recoverable.

03 / 07

Where manufacturers overpay

These are the errors we look for first on manufacturing accounts.

Wrong rate class

A plant that added a shift or a high-load line may qualify for a large-power or high-load-factor schedule. A plant that shrank may be paying minimums sized for a larger operation. See rate misclassification.

Demand and ratchet errors

Billed kW that does not match the meter, ratchets set by the wrong month, or demand from a stuck register. See demand charge errors.

Meter multiplier errors

When a meter, current transformer or service is changed for new equipment, the multiplier on the bill must change too. If it does not, every kWh and kW is scaled wrong. See meter multiplier errors.

Corporate classification errors

Production accounts set up as commercial, or with the wrong business code, can lose industrial rates and rider eligibility. See corporate classification errors.

Gas on the wrong schedule

Plants with steady, high gas use left on general-service schedules instead of large-volume or transportation service.

Seasonal rate errors

Summer or winter pricing that starts early or ends late. See seasonal rate errors.

Capacity and transmission tags

In some markets, a plant's load during a few system peak hours sets a year of capacity or transmission cost. Wrong tags carry through every month. See capacity tag errors.

Idle and closed plants

Accounts at closed or consolidated sites that keep billing minimums, customer charges or ratchets. See closed-site accounts.

04 / 07

What we have found at manufacturers

At a national steel company that already had an energy manager, an independent audit found 17 misclassified accounts in 7 states. One natural gas account in San Antonio, Texas was billed on Schedule G when it qualified for large-volume Schedule LVG, a difference of $33,554 a year on that account alone.

National steel company, refunds$374,326From 17 misclassified accounts in 7 states.
Same client, ongoing savings$150,000+A year in ongoing savings.

Total documented savings for other manufacturing clients:

Industrial equipment and precision medical, 56 locations$1,778,902
Metal coating and galvanizing, 60 locations$421,845

Since 2000, recoveries have most often equaled 3% to 15% of annual utility spend, depending on the utilities involved and the billing history. Read the full steel company case study or browse all case studies.

05 / 07

How an audit works for a manufacturer

The audit is an off-site review of bills, meter data and tariffs. There is no hardware to install, no site visit and no production interruption.

  1. Account list and authorization

    You send a list of accounts or one recent bill per plant, and sign a letter of authorization (LOA) so we can request billing history and meter data directly from each utility.

  2. Billing history and tariff review

    We review 36 to 48 months of bills for each account against the tariffs in force at the time, plant by plant.

  3. Findings

    First findings usually arrive in 30 to 60 days, with the tariff section and bill lines behind each one. Nothing is changed on any account without your written approval.

  4. Claims and corrections

    We file claims with the utility and move accounts to the correct rate. Refunds usually take a further 60 to 120 days. How far back a refund can go is set by each state and utility, typically 1 to 5 years.

What helps us start faster

  • A list of plants with addresses, utilities and account numbers
  • Any plant changes in the last five years: new lines, added shifts, idled buildings, new transformers or meters
  • Which plants have on-site generation, interruptible service or gas transportation contracts

The fee is contingent: usually 15% to 50% of refunds and verified savings, paid only when you receive them. Utilities never pay us. If you want to test the process first, a 15-account pilot audit or a free rate class check is available.

06 / 07

After the audit

The audit can be engaged on its own. Where clients want more, the same account data supports:

07 / 07

Questions buyers ask

Fees, results, and how an audit fits beside the broker or energy manager you already have.

What is an industrial utility bill audit?

A review of a plant's electricity and natural gas bills against the utility's tariffs and meter data, to find charges that were billed incorrectly and recover them. For plants, most findings involve demand, rate class, voltage, gas service or account classification.

Does an audit require a site visit or shutdown?

No. The audit works from bills, meter data and tariffs obtained under a letter of authorization. Nothing is installed and production is not interrupted.

We already have an energy manager. Is an audit still useful?

Often, yes. Energy managers usually focus on usage and supply contracts. At a national steel company with an energy manager in place, an independent audit still found 17 misclassified accounts and $374,326 in refunds.

How far back can refunds go?

Typically 1 to 5 years, depending on state rules and the utility's tariff. We review 36 to 48 months of bills to find what is recoverable.

Who usually signs off at a manufacturer?

Usually the CFO or controller, sometimes the VP of operations: whoever can sign the letter of authorization for billing data.

What does it cost?

Nothing upfront. The fee is usually 15% to 50% of refunds and verified savings, paid only when you receive them. See pricing.

Sources

  1. US EIA, Use of energy explained: energy use in industry, industrial sector share (33%) of US energy consumption in 2025.
  2. US EIA, 2022 Manufacturing Energy Consumption Survey results, $191.7 billion purchased energy spend with electricity 36% and natural gas 26%; 94% of natural gas not switchable; 8% of establishments with submetering; 78% of natural gas spend with nonutility suppliers.
  3. US EIA, MECS 2022 Table 5.1, end uses of fuel consumption, machine drive 396,282 of 783,620 million kWh of manufacturing net electricity.

Find out what your bills should have cost.

Send one recent bill per site, or a list of accounts. We tell you where we expect findings before you sign anything. No upfront audit fee.