Capacity tag (PLC) errors
In PJM, a facility's capacity cost is roughly its peak load contribution (PLC, or capacity tag) multiplied by the capacity clearing price. This page explains how capacity and transmission tags are calculated, where they go wrong, what a wrong tag costs and how to check yours.
A capacity tag error is an incorrect PLC or transmission obligation (network service peak load, or NSPL) on an account in the PJM region. Because the tag is calculated once from a few hours of last summer's load and then billed every day of the following year, one wrong input inflates twelve months of capacity or transmission charges.
01 / 07
Why the tag now matters so much
PJM operates the grid serving more than 67 million people in all or parts of 13 states and the District of Columbia. Its Base Residual Auction sets the capacity price for each delivery year, which runs June 1 to May 31. That price has risen sharply:
| Delivery year | RTO clearing price ($/MW-day) | Value of 1 MW of tag for a full year |
|---|---|---|
| 2024/25 | $28.92 | About $10,600 |
| 2025/26 | $269.92 | About $98,500 |
| 2026/27 | $329.17 (at the cap) | About $120,100 |
| 2027/28 | $333.44 (at the cap) | About $121,700 |
| 2028/29 | $325.00 (at the cap) | About $118,600 |
The last column is the clearing price times 365 days, before loss and scaling factors and contract terms. Each megawatt of tag is now worth about $120,000 a year at the auction rate, so a tag that is even slightly too high costs real money. The 2028/29 auction also fell 6,831 MW short of PJM's reliability requirement, the second shortfall in a row. More on PJM capacity prices and industrial budgets.
02 / 07
How a capacity tag is set
PJM Manual 19 sets the starting point. For each summer, PJM gathers hourly metered load from June 1 through September 30, adds back load that was reduced by demand response, and identifies the five highest non-holiday weekday daily peaks across the whole PJM system. These are the 5CP. PJM typically releases them in mid-October. Each electric distribution company (EDC) then allocates its zone's share to customers using its own method. A typical method, based on published procedures from Dominion Energy and Delmarva Power, works like this:
Collect load in the five peak hours
Interval-metered accounts use their hourly load in each 5CP hour. Accounts without interval meters get load from rate-class profiles, and new accounts often get a class average.
Add back curtailed load
Load reduced during a PJM demand response event is added back, so being paid to curtail in a PJM event does not lower next year's tag.
Apply a loss factor
The average of the five hours is grossed up by a loss expansion factor that depends on service voltage.
Scale to the zone
All customer values are scaled to add up to the obligation PJM assigned to the zone. The scaling factor changes every year.
Apply for the delivery year
The result is the account's PLC from June 1 to May 31. Utilities pass it to suppliers, and some show it in the customer portal; PECO, for example, lists current and pending PLC with start and end dates.
The transmission tag works differently
The NSPL sets the account's share of network transmission charges, and the method varies more by zone. ComEd bases it on the single highest zonal load hour of the summer and applies it January through December of the next year. Dominion allocates its zone's annual peak using each customer's average of 12 monthly coincident peaks. PJM publishes zonal network service peak loads each year. Because the two tags use different peak hours and different effective dates, a site can have a correct PLC and a wrong NSPL, or the reverse. See charges by market for how capacity and transmission are billed in each region.
03 / 07
How tags go wrong
- Wrong load data. Interval or meter data used for the peak hours is wrong, estimated or from the wrong meter.
- Meter multiplier errors. If the meter's multiplier is wrong, the peak-hour load is scaled wrong too. See meter multiplier errors.
- Factors applied incorrectly. A utility scaling or loss factor is applied incorrectly, for example a secondary-voltage loss factor on a primary-voltage account.
- Profile tags on interval meters. An account with an interval meter is still tagged from a class profile or class average, often after a new service, meter exchange or acquisition.
- Stale tags. The tag was not updated after a site closed, curtailed load or changed its operations, or a supplier keeps billing last year's tag after the June 1 changeover.
- Supplier mismatch. The supplier bills on a different tag than the utility assigned.
- Transmission errors. A transmission obligation (NSPL) is miscalculated or mismatched with the account.
A tag can also be correct and still expensive: a start-up test that fell on a system peak hour sets a high tag under the rules. That is an operational issue for next summer, not a billing error.
How it shows up on a bill
Capacity may appear as its own line, as a pass-through on the supplier invoice, or folded into a fixed supply price. Common names include PLC, capacity obligation, ICAP tag and RPM charge. Signs of a problem:
- A capacity charge that did not fall after a site cut load or closed a line the summer before.
- A PLC that is higher than the account's metered peak demand last summer.
- A tag on the supplier invoice that differs from the one in the utility portal.
- Identical tags across sites with very different loads, which suggests class averages.
Illustrative example, not a client result
A plant on primary voltage averages 4.0 MW during the five peak hours. After a meter exchange the year before, the utility's records still carry the old meter's multiplier, so the peak-hour data reads 15% high and the plant is tagged at 4.6 MW. At $329.17 per MW-day, the extra 0.6 MW costs about $72,100 over the 2026/27 delivery year before loss and scaling factors. The same error also inflates every monthly energy and demand charge, so both should be traced back to the meter.
04 / 07
Who is most exposed
Exposure is highest where tags are large, loads change and no one reviews the tag each year:
- Plants with high summer load in Pennsylvania, Ohio, Illinois, New Jersey, Maryland, Virginia and other PJM states: manufacturing, steel and metals, plastics and food processing.
- Refrigerated and temperature-controlled sites, whose load peaks on the same hot afternoons as the grid. See cold storage and logistics.
- Sites that changed in the last two years: closures, curtailments, new lines, meter exchanges and acquisitions. See utility accounts when sites change.
- Accounts on pass-through supply contracts, where the tag flows straight to the invoice at the current zonal price.
Texas has a parallel system: transmission costs in ERCOT are set from four summer intervals. See ERCOT 4CP transmission charges. For state detail, see the briefings on ComEd capacity charges in Illinois and the New Jersey capacity investigation.
05 / 07
How to check yours
Get each account's current tags
Get each account's current PLC and transmission tag from the utility or your supplier, with the effective dates, and the pending PLC for the next delivery year if it has been posted.
Recompute the tag
Pull interval data for the peak hours the utility used and recompute the tag with the utility's published method and factors.
Check the inputs
Confirm the meter, multiplier, service voltage and loss factor, and whether the account was tagged from interval data or a profile.
Compare supplier and utility
Compare the tag on supplier invoices with the utility's figure, month by month, especially in June and January when tags change.
Read the contract
Confirm whether your contract fixes capacity cost or passes it through, and what happens when a tag is corrected.
Plan for next summer
Then plan peak reduction for next summer, which lowers future tags.
06 / 07
How it is corrected and how far back refunds go
When the error is in the data or the calculation, the utility can recalculate the tag and send the corrected value to the supplier and PJM. Whether past charges are refunded depends on two sets of rules: the utility's tariff and settlement procedures for the tag itself, and the supply contract for the capacity charges the supplier billed. Utility billing errors are refunded within the period each state allows; see how far back utilities refund overcharges, by state.
Discovery checks capacity treatment, tags and billing determinants as part of audits for PJM accounts, before any procurement decision. The audit is off-site and contingency-based, and a letter of authorization lets us request tags and interval data from each utility. If you are about to buy power, energy procurement should start from corrected tags, because suppliers price capacity on the tag they are given.
07 / 07
Questions buyers ask
What is a peak load contribution (PLC)?
A PLC, or capacity tag, is an account's assigned share of the PJM system peak. The utility calculates it from the account's load during PJM's peak hours of the prior summer, applies its own scaling factors, and the result sets the account's capacity obligation for the delivery year that runs June 1 to May 31.
How much is a capacity tag worth?
At the 2026/27 clearing price of $329.17 per MW-day, each 1 MW of tag is roughly $120,000 a year at the wholesale auction rate, before loss and scaling factors and contract terms. Retail bills differ, but the scale is why a wrong tag matters.
Can a wrong tag be corrected?
Often, when the error is in the data or calculation, such as wrong interval data, a missed scaling factor or a tag carried over after a site closed or cut load. Correction and any refund depend on the utility's rules and the supplier contract.
Does lowering peak load next summer help?
Yes, for future delivery years. Reducing load during likely system peak hours lowers the next tag. That is an operational strategy, often with a demand-response provider; checking that today's tag is calculated correctly is an audit task.
What is the difference between the PLC and the NSPL?
The PLC sets capacity cost and is based on the five PJM system peak hours of the prior summer. The NSPL sets transmission cost and is based on the transmission zone's peak, using a method that differs by utility. They usually take effect on different dates.
We have a fixed-price contract. Does the tag still matter?
Yes. Suppliers usually price capacity into a fixed contract using the tag at the time of the quote, and some contracts pass through changes in tags or capacity costs. A wrong tag can raise the fixed price or the pass-through.
Sources
- PJM, Who we are, states served and population of more than 67 million.
- PJM, 2026/2027 Base Residual Auction report, $329.17 clearing price at the cap, with 2024/25 ($28.92) and 2025/26 ($269.92) prices.
- PJM, 2027/2028 Base Residual Auction report, $333.44 clearing price at the cap.
- PJM Inside Lines, 2028/2029 Base Residual Auction results, $325 clearing price at the cap and 6,831 MW shortfall against the reliability requirement.
- PJM Manual 19, Load Forecasting and Analysis, section 4.3, 5CP method: June 1 to September 30, load drop add-back, five highest non-holiday weekday peaks, mid-October release.
- Dominion Energy, Peak load contribution and network service peak load, utility PLC steps (load add-back, loss expansion factor, zonal scaling), June 1 to May 31 effective period, 12-CP NSPL.
- PJM Open Access Transmission Tariff, Attachment M-2 (ComEd), PJM Five Peaks definition and NSPL based on the highest summer zonal load, effective January to December.
- PJM Open Access Transmission Tariff, Delmarva PLC procedures, profiled loads for non-interval customers and class profiles for new customers.
- PECO, View account usage data, current and pending capacity PLC and NSPL shown to business customers.
- PJM, Billing, settlements and credit, annual publication of network service peak loads.
Find out what your bills should have cost.
Send one recent bill per site, or a list of accounts. We tell you where we expect findings before you sign anything. No upfront audit fee.