Utility bill audits for RNG producers
Renewable natural gas (RNG) plants run blowers, compressors and upgrading equipment around the clock, and fueling stations add compression loads of their own. Across many states and utilities, those electricity and natural gas bills are set up quickly and rarely checked again. We audit them against the tariffs that govern them, recover overcharges on contingency and correct the accounts going forward.
01 / 07
Why utility costs matter for RNG producers
RNG is biogas from landfills, farms, wastewater plants and food waste that has been cleaned and upgraded so it can replace fossil natural gas. The industry has grown fast. The RNG Coalition marked the 500th operational RNG facility in North America in June 2025, and reported 130 facilities added in 2025 after 114 in 2024, two record years in a row.
- 102 and 135
- Landfill and livestock farm RNG projects operating in the US in 2023, according to EPA, up from 45 and 7 in 2017.
- 25 to 30 kWh
- Electricity per MMBtu of RNG assumed by a 2022 study prepared by ICF for the Michigan Public Service Commission, depending on feedstock, plus natural gas equal to 5% to 6% of product for processing.
- 84%
- Share of the nearly 64 Bcf of natural gas used as US transportation fuel in 2022 that came from RNG qualifying for cellulosic RINs, 55 Bcf in all (EIA).
- 134 vs 57
- Livestock digester projects making CNG versus those injecting into a pipeline in 2024. EPA reports CNG vehicle fuel is now the most common end use for farm biogas.
Electricity is a large recurring cost at RNG plants. Raw biogas holds 45% to 65% methane, and pipeline-quality RNG usually holds 96% to 98%, so the gas has to be compressed, dried and separated, then compressed again to meet pipeline pressure. Blowers, chillers, pumps, digester mixers and heating add parasitic load: energy the plant uses to make its product.
Two things make RNG bills easy to get wrong. Rate classes are assigned at service application, based on estimated load, before the plant ramps up. And a producer with plants and stations in many states deals with a different utility, tariff and regulator at each one.
02 / 07
How RNG sites are billed
Production plants, interconnect sites and fueling stations have different load shapes, and each is billed differently.
| Site type | Typical load | Tariff features that matter |
|---|---|---|
| Upgrading and production plant | Steady, high load from compression, blowers, chillers and upgrading equipment, 24 hours a day. | Large general service or industrial schedules, high-load-factor options, service voltage, demand ratchets, power factor, capacity or transmission tags in some markets. |
| Digester and farm sites | Pumps, mixers and digester heating, often on rural distribution lines. | Agricultural or general service schedules, seasonal rates, estimated reads at remote meters. |
| Natural gas used on site | Gas for thermal oxidizers, heating or processing, sometimes at volumes large enough for a large-volume schedule. | Sales versus transportation service, large-volume schedules, therm factors, balancing charges. |
| CNG fueling stations | Compressors that run hard while trucks fill, then sit idle. High peaks, low average use. | Demand charges and ratchets, which can outweigh energy charges. Time-of-use or lower-demand options where a tariff offers them. |
Illustrative example, not a client result
A plant injects 1,000 MMBtu of RNG a day. At 28 kWh per MMBtu, it uses about 28,000 kWh a day, or roughly 10 million kWh a year. At an assumed delivered price of 10 cents per kWh, that is about $1 million a year in electricity at one site. A rate class or demand error of a few percent on a bill that size repeats every month until someone finds it.
03 / 07
Where RNG producers overpay
These are the errors we look for first on production and fueling accounts.
Rate class set at startup and never revisited
The schedule chosen from estimated load before commissioning may not fit the plant at full output. See rate misclassification.
Ratchets from commissioning or restarts
A peak during testing or a restart after an outage can set billed demand for months. See demand charge errors.
Fueling station demand charges
Station compressors create short, high peaks. Billed demand that does not match interval data, or a schedule that penalizes low load factor when a better one exists.
Construction accounts left open
Temporary service used during construction that keeps billing after the permanent service is live. See site changes.
Meter multiplier errors at new services
New services with current transformers are a common source of wrong multipliers. See meter multiplier errors.
Gas accounts on the wrong service
Plants and stations eligible for transportation or large-volume service left on sales or general-service schedules.
Capacity and transmission tags
In PJM, ERCOT and other markets, load during a few system peaks sets a year of cost. See capacity tag errors and ERCOT 4CP charges.
Account classification
Production accounts set up as commercial, so industrial rates and riders never apply. See corporate classification errors.
Estimated reads at remote sites
Landfill and farm meters billed on estimates, then trued up in one large bill. See estimated reads.
04 / 07
What we have found at an RNG producer
A renewable natural gas producer with production and fueling sites in more than 12 states had overcharges and supply costs spread across many utilities and suppliers. An audit of every account, together with competitive energy buying, recovered refunds in 10 states and cut ongoing costs.
Where the monthly savings came from:
- $187,455 a month from correcting the billing errors the audit found.
- $167,000 a month on average from a competitive supply request for proposals (RFP) for one large New Jersey electric account.
- More than $50,000 a month expected from correcting the transport gas setup at 13 sites.
Since 2000, recoveries have most often equaled 3% to 15% of annual utility spend, depending on the utilities and billing history. Results for any one producer depend on its sites and tariffs. Read the full RNG producer case study or all case studies.
05 / 07
How an audit works for an RNG portfolio
The audit is an off-site review of bills, interval meter data and tariffs. There is no hardware, no site visit and no interruption to production or injection, which matters for remote landfill and farm sites.
Accounts and authorization
You send a list of accounts or one recent bill per site, and sign a letter of authorization (LOA) so we can request billing history and meter data from each utility.
History and tariff review
We review 36 to 48 months of electricity and natural gas bills, or the full history for newer plants, against the tariffs in force at the time.
Findings
First findings usually arrive in 30 to 60 days, each tied to the tariff section and bill lines behind it. No change is made to any account without your written approval.
Claims and corrections
We file claims and move accounts to the correct terms. Refunds usually take a further 60 to 120 days. How far back a refund can go is set by each state and utility, typically 1 to 5 years.
What to gather
- Every production plant, digester site and fueling station, with utility and account numbers
- Commercial operation dates, and any construction or temporary service accounts
- Expansions, new compressors or upgrading trains added since startup
- Gas transportation and electricity supply contracts by site
The fee is contingent: usually 15% to 50% of refunds and verified savings, paid only when you receive them. Utilities never pay us. A 15-account pilot audit or a free rate class check is available.
06 / 07
After the audit
The audit can be engaged on its own. For producers adding sites each year, the corrected inventory also supports:
- Energy procurement for plant electricity and station gas in deregulated markets, timed with market guidance. Any supplier commission is disclosed up front.
- Utility bill pay across every state, with a 30 to 45 day transition and cost allocation by plant or project entity. Water and sewer bills can be included in bill pay.
- TaraBase reporting on savings, usage and contracts, with Scope 2 data for purchased electricity at each site.
- Multi-site energy management so new plants are set up correctly from the first bill.
07 / 07
Questions buyers ask
Fees, results, and how an audit fits beside the broker or energy manager you already have.
Do you audit fueling stations as well as production plants?
Yes. Station electricity and gas accounts are audited alongside production sites. The RNG producer in our case study had both.
Our plants are new. Is there enough history to audit?
Usually, yes. New plants are where rate classes chosen from estimated load, commissioning ratchets and leftover construction accounts are most common. We review whatever history exists.
Do you review interconnection agreements or credit revenue?
No. The audit covers electricity and natural gas bills at your sites. Water and sewer can be included in bill pay, but are not audited.
Can you handle plants in many states?
Yes. We audit across the US and Canada. The producer in our case study had sites in more than 12 states and refunds in 10.
Does the audit need a site visit?
No. It works from bills, meter data and tariffs obtained under a letter of authorization.
What does it cost?
Nothing upfront. The fee is usually 15% to 50% of refunds and verified savings, paid only when you receive them. See pricing.
Sources
- RNG Coalition, 500 operational RNG facilities in North America (June 2025), the 500th operational facility.
- RNG Coalition, 2025 yielded record-high annual facility growth for RNG (March 2026), 130 facilities added in 2025 and 114 in 2024.
- US EPA Landfill Methane Outreach Program, Renewable natural gas, landfill (102) and agricultural (135) RNG projects operating in 2023 and in 2017 (45 and 7); raw biogas 45% to 65% methane; pipeline RNG 96% to 98%.
- ICF for the Michigan Public Service Commission, Michigan Renewable Natural Gas Study (September 2022), electricity assumptions of 25 to 30 kWh per MMBtu and natural gas of 5% to 6% of product.
- US EIA, Today in Energy, December 11, 2023, 55 Bcf of RNG qualifying for cellulosic RINs in 2022, about 84% of the nearly 64 Bcf of natural gas used as transportation fuel.
- US EPA AgSTAR, Data and trends, 134 CNG and 57 pipeline livestock digester projects in 2024; CNG vehicle fuel as the most common end use.
Find out what your bills should have cost.
Send one recent bill per site, or a list of accounts. We tell you where we expect findings before you sign anything. No upfront audit fee.