Rate misclassification
Rate misclassification is billing a utility account under a rate schedule that does not match its actual load, usage pattern, service voltage or facility type. It is the most common source of large recoveries in Discovery's audits, because the error repeats on every bill until someone reclassifies the account.
How accounts end up on the wrong schedule, how to check yours, and how utilities and regulators treat refunds when the class is wrong.
01 / 07
What a rate class is, and why it drifts
Every electric and gas account is assigned a rate schedule (also called a rate class or tariff) from the utility's filed rate book. Each schedule has an applicability section that says who may take service on it: a minimum or maximum demand in kW, a monthly or annual volume, a service voltage or delivery pressure, a type of use, or a contract term.
The thresholds are specific. Georgia Power's Power and Light Large schedule, for example, applies to customers with a demand of 500 kW or greater, calculated from 95% of summer peaks or 60% of winter peaks over the current and previous 11 months, and requires a five-year contract. CPS Energy in San Antonio offers a general-service gas rate (G) for cooking, heating and lighting and a separate Large Volume Gas rate (LVG) for commercial, industrial and processing use, with a minimum billing demand of 600 CCF a day.
The class is usually set once, when service begins, from what the customer tells the utility. CPS Energy's terms are typical: the utility assigns the schedule based on the applicant's statement of the service desired and the amount and manner of use, and any later change in rate schedule needed because the customer's circumstances changed must be brought to the utility's attention by the customer. In practice, the account stays where it was put.
How it happens
- The site changes and the account does not. A plant expands, adds equipment or changes shifts, and its load outgrows its original class. Or a site shrinks and keeps paying minimums sized for a larger operation.
- An acquisition carries old assumptions forward. A site is acquired and its accounts are never reviewed. The new owner inherits the seller's rate choices along with the meters.
- The utility restructures its rates. In a rate case, schedules are merged, split or closed, and the utility maps accounts to new schedules imperfectly.
- A commercial class is applied where an industrial or large-volume class is available. This is common on gas accounts, where a general-service schedule is the default.
- Optional schedules are never revisited. Where a site qualifies for two or more schedules, nobody rechecks which one is cheaper as its load profile changes.
02 / 07
How it shows up on a bill
It usually does not. The bill is calculated correctly for the class it has been assigned; the class itself is simply the wrong one. A variance report sees nothing, because the error is the baseline. The signs are indirect:
- A rate code that is the same as small offices or retail sites on the same utility, on a plant or warehouse that runs two or three shifts.
- No demand charge on a large account, or a demand charge on a schedule built for low-load-factor customers when the site runs steadily.
- A gas account with steady, high monthly volume billed at a flat general-service price per CCF or therm.
Illustrative example, not a client result
Using the base charges in CPS Energy's published G and LVG gas sheets effective February 1, 2024, consider a site that uses a steady 30,000 CCF a month (about 1,000 CCF a day). On G, the base bill is about $16,060 a month ($10.36 plus $0.535 per CCF). On LVG, it is about $12,212 in a winter month ($412.18, plus $1.38 per CCF a day of billing demand, plus $0.34732 per CCF) and about $11,872 in other months. That is roughly $48,900 a year, about 25% of base charges, before gas cost adjustments and other charges. A site with a sharp winter peak and low summer use would see a different result, because LVG's billing demand in April through November is set by the previous winter's peak.
03 / 07
Who is most exposed
The risk concentrates where load changes and nobody owns the tariff.
- Plants that grew, shrank or changed shifts. Manufacturers, steel and metals and plastics plants move across demand and load-factor thresholds as lines are added or idled.
- Gas-intensive sites. Ovens, dryers, boilers and furnaces at food processors, grain and oilseed operations and galvanizers often qualify for large-volume or transportation gas service.
- Portfolios built by acquisition. Chemical distributors, warehousing and distribution networks and private equity portfolio companies add sites with whatever classes the seller chose. See utility costs in acquisitions.
A related error is a corporate classification error, where the account's business type, not its rate schedule, is wrong. The two often appear together.
04 / 07
How to check your own accounts
Work account by account, with 12 months of bills and the utility's current rate book.
Find the rate code
Note the schedule name or code printed on the bill for each meter. Some bills show it only on a detail page.
Read the applicability section
Pull that schedule from the utility's tariff and read who it applies to: demand, volume, voltage or pressure, end use and contract terms.
Compare the account's real profile
Check 12 months of billed demand, usage, load factor (energy used divided by peak demand times hours) and service voltage against the thresholds.
List every schedule the site qualifies for
Include optional, time-of-use, large-volume, interruptible and transportation schedules, not just the obvious alternative.
Model a full year on each
Recalculate twelve months of bills on each eligible schedule, including minimum bills, ratchets and riders. A schedule that wins in summer can lose in winter.
Date any change at the site
Record when lines were added, shifts changed, equipment was removed or the site was acquired. The date of the change often decides how far back a refund can reach.
Check sister sites
If one site on a utility is misclassified, check every other site on that utility. The same assumption is often repeated.
For a quick first pass, Discovery's free rate class check looks at one recent bill per site and, within 10 business days, flags which accounts look like they are on the wrong rate class, with no fee and no obligation.
05 / 07
How it is corrected, and how far back refunds go
Correction starts with a written request to the utility, citing the tariff's applicability language and the account's usage. The utility moves the account going forward, often from the next billing cycle. The past depends on what kind of error it was.
- The account was not eligible for the schedule it was billed on. Regulators generally treat this as a billing error. Idaho's rules, for example, say a customer billed under a rate for which it was not eligible has been billed under an incorrect rate, and the utility must recalculate past bills. Maryland's rules require the total overcharge from an incorrect application of the rate schedule to be refunded or credited.
- The account was eligible, but a cheaper schedule was available. This is often treated as a customer choice, not an error. CPS Energy's terms say a more favorable rate schedule will not be made effective retroactively, and that the utility will help select the most advantageous rate on request. Idaho's rule also excuses a utility that acted in good faith on information the customer provided.
Time limits differ by state. Idaho limits corrected billing to three years when the start of the problem can be dated, and six months when it cannot. Maryland caps a utility's back-billing of undercharges at 12 months in most cases, but sets no such cap on refunds of overcharges from a rate-schedule error. The rules are not symmetrical, and many states leave the period to each utility's tariff. See how far back utilities refund overcharges, by state, and overcharge recovery for the steps from finding to refund.
06 / 07
What it looks like in practice
At a national steel company that already had an energy management provider for procurement and auditing, an independent audit found 17 accounts in 7 states on the wrong class, at facilities in Indiana, Massachusetts, Nebraska, Minnesota, Colorado, Texas and Missouri. Separately, a San Antonio gas account qualified to move from Schedule G to large-volume Schedule LVG: CPS Energy's own rate comparison simulated $33,554 a year in savings, 22.40% of that account's cost. No plant operations changed.
Read the national steel company case and the diversified agribusiness case.
07 / 07
Questions buyers ask
What is utility rate-class verification?
Confirming that a commercial or industrial account is billed under the correct rate schedule for its actual load profile, usage pattern and facility type, using the eligibility criteria in the utility's own tariff.
Will the utility move us automatically when our load changes?
Usually not. Utilities rarely reclassify accounts proactively, so classes set years ago persist after expansions, equipment changes or shifts in operating hours. Many tariffs put the duty to report a change on the customer.
Is a misclassification refundable?
Often, for the recoverable period the state and utility allow, plus lower bills from the corrected class going forward. A site that was never eligible for its schedule has a stronger refund claim than one that was eligible but could have chosen a cheaper option, which some utilities correct only from the date of the request.
How far back can a rate misclassification refund go?
It depends on the state and the utility's tariff. Recoverable periods are typically 1 to 5 years. Some rules count from when the error began if it can be dated, which is why the date of a site change matters. Discovery reviews 36 to 48 months of bills on each account.
Does this apply to natural gas as well as electricity?
Yes. Gas utilities have general-service, large-volume, interruptible and transportation schedules with their own volume thresholds. A plant with steady, high gas use on a general-service schedule is a common finding.
Sources
- Georgia Power, Power and Light Large Schedule PLL-18, 500 kW applicability threshold calculated from 95% of summer and 60% of winter demands, five-year contract term.
- CPS Energy, Large Volume Gas Rate LVG (effective February 1, 2024), applicability, charges and 600 CCF a day minimum billing demand used in the illustrative example.
- CPS Energy, General Service Gas Rate G (effective February 1, 2024), applicability and charges used in the illustrative example.
- CPS Energy, Customer Terms and Conditions, selection of rate schedule, customer duty to report changes, no retroactive move to a more favorable schedule.
- Idaho Public Utilities Commission, IDAPA 31.21.01, Rule 203, definition of billing under an incorrect rate, recalculation of past bills, good-faith exception, three-year and six-month limits.
- Maryland, COMAR 20.50.04.05 (Adjustment of Bills), refund of overcharges from incorrect application of the rate schedule and the 12-month limit on back-billing undercharges.
Find out what your bills should have cost.
Send one recent bill per site, or a list of accounts. We tell you where we expect findings before you sign anything. No upfront audit fee.