Utility bill audits for agribusiness
Elevators, mills, crush plants and irrigation systems sit in rural utility and cooperative territories with their own agricultural schedules, optional riders and seasonal loads. A rate class chosen years ago, or a rider signed for an operating pattern that has since changed, can cost an agribusiness every month without anyone noticing. We audit electricity and natural gas bills for multi-site agribusinesses off-site and on contingency.
01 / 07
Why utility costs matter in agribusiness
Agribusiness energy use is shaped by the crop calendar. Grain handling and drying run hard for a few weeks at harvest. Mills and crush plants run steadily on motors and steam. Irrigation pumps run through the growing season and sit idle the rest of the year. Federal data show the scale.
- 338 trillion Btu
- Energy used as fuel by US grain and oilseed milling plants in 2022, according to the US Energy Information Administration's Manufacturing Energy Consumption Survey (MECS).
- About 70%
- Share of that segment's electricity used for machine drive: the motors behind conveyors, hammer mills, roller mills, fans and presses (42 of 60 trillion Btu).
- 170 trillion Btu
- Natural gas used by grain and oilseed milling, about 72% of it as boiler fuel (122 trillion Btu) to raise steam and hot water for processing.
- $3.3 billion
- Spent by US farms on energy for pumping irrigation water in 2023, according to the USDA's Irrigation and Water Management Survey.
Three things make agribusiness bills harder to check than most. First, loads are seasonal, and many tariffs carry a demand ratchet: a minimum demand charge set by a past peak. A harvest peak can set billing demand for the rest of the year. Second, sites are spread across investor-owned utilities, municipal utilities and electric cooperatives, each with its own rate book. Third, the industry consolidates. Elevators and plants change hands, and their utility accounts carry forward on the previous owner's rate classes and riders.
02 / 07
How agribusiness sites are billed
Many utilities offer schedules written for agriculture, and they come with eligibility tests. Georgia Power's published agricultural rates are a good example of how specific these can be.
| Georgia Power schedule | Eligibility test (as published) |
|---|---|
| Seasonal Agricultural Service | At least 80% of annual kWh in any six consecutive months, demand under 500 kW, 5-year contract. |
| Seasonal Agricultural Service, Non-Demand | At least 85% of annual kWh between October and May. |
| Agricultural Process Service | More than 50% of business activity in agricultural processing or storage, with product owned by individual farms. |
| Irrigation Off-Peak Service | Irrigation use, one service point at standard voltage, off-peak usage requirements, 5-year contract. |
Other utilities use different names and thresholds, but the pattern is common: an agricultural or seasonal rate that is cheaper if the site meets a usage test, and more expensive, or not allowed, if it does not. A site that met the test when it was set up may fail it after an expansion, and a site that never applied may now qualify.
Other tariff features that matter
- Demand charges and ratchets. Dryers, aeration fans, legs and conveyors all start at harvest. The peak they set can carry into winter bills through a ratchet.
- Riders. Optional add-ons to a base rate, such as interruptible credits, economic development discounts or program charges. Some are worth keeping. Some cost more than they return once operations change.
- Seasonal and minimum charges. Irrigation and seasonal accounts can carry annual minimums or off-season customer charges, which keep billing when a pump or elevator sits idle.
- Natural gas for dryers and boilers. Dryer and boiler gas can be on firm or interruptible service, and on utility sales or third-party transportation service. Each has its own terms and penalties.
03 / 07
Where agribusiness companies overpay
Rate classes that no longer fit
A site stays on the general service schedule it opened on, though its usage now fits an agricultural, seasonal or large-power schedule. See rate misclassification.
Optional riders that stopped paying
A rider signed for one operating pattern stays on after the pattern changes. The bill shows the rider charge every month, and the credit it was meant to earn never arrives.
Stuck or failed demand meters
The billed kW is identical month after month, through harvest and off-season alike. That pattern usually means the meter is not recording. See demand charge errors.
Ratchets that outlast the peak
Billing demand set by a harvest peak keeps applying after the ratchet period ends, or is calculated on the wrong months.
Seasonal prices on the wrong dates
Summer or peak-season pricing starts early or ends late against the tariff's dates. See seasonal rate errors.
Idle and sold sites still billing
An elevator closed, consolidated or sold keeps an account in the company's name. See closed-site accounts and site changes.
Multipliers after a service upgrade
A new dryer or larger motor brings a new transformer or meter, and the multiplier in the billing system is not updated. See meter multiplier errors.
Illustrative example
An elevator's demand peaks at 900 kW in October during harvest. Its tariff carries an 80% ratchet, so billing demand cannot fall below 720 kW for the next 11 months, even when the site draws 150 kW in spring. If the utility applies the ratchet to an account whose tariff does not include one, or keeps applying it after the 11 months, every one of those bills is overstated. This example is illustrative, not a Discovery result.
04 / 07
What we have found in agribusiness
A diversified agribusiness with grain, flour milling and soybean processing operations in three states was audited after it was acquired. The audit tested each account rather than carrying forward the prior owner's assumptions, and found five separate issues: rate classes that no longer fit, an optional tariff rider the business could leave, a demand meter that had been stuck for months, and a rate-schedule correction.
None of the five issues looked related until each account was checked against its own tariff. That is typical of agribusiness portfolios, where every utility writes its schedules differently. Across all industries since 2000, recoveries have most often equaled 3% to 15% of annual utility spend, depending on the utilities and the billing history.
05 / 07
How an audit works for an agribusiness
Send a list of sites and accounts
Elevators, mills, crush and feed plants, dryers, irrigation pumps and offices, or one recent bill per account. A 15-account pilot is available.
Sign a letter of authorization
The letter of authorization (LOA) lets us request billing history, meter data and rate details from each utility and cooperative directly.
We review 36 to 48 months of bills
Three or four years covers several harvests, which is what it takes to see ratchets, seasonal pricing and stuck meters. The review is off-site: no hardware, no site visit and no interruption at harvest.
First findings in 30 to 60 days
Each finding cites the tariff and the bills it affects. No account is changed without your written approval.
Refunds, usually 60 to 120 days later
The recoverable period is typically 1 to 5 years, set by each state and utility. There is no upfront fee: the fee is usually 15% to 50% of refunds and verified savings, paid only when you receive them.
Helpful to have ready
- Harvest and operating seasons for each site, and any sites that run year-round.
- Dates of new dryers, legs, bins, presses or service upgrades.
- Rider and contract paperwork, including interruptible or economic development agreements.
- Sites bought, sold, closed or idled in the last five years.
06 / 07
After the audit
Each of these can be engaged on its own.
- Energy procurement for sites in deregulated electricity or gas markets, including gas supply for dryers and boilers. Any supplier commission is disclosed up front.
- Utility bill pay, so seasonal and idle accounts are paid on time and closed when they should be. Water bills can be included in bill pay.
- Cost allocation by site, division or commodity line.
- TaraBase reporting of savings, usage, contracts and Scope 2 data for food and fuel customers who ask for it.
If you are buying or integrating sites, utility costs in acquisitions sets out what to check after close.
07 / 07
Questions buyers ask
Fees, results, and how an audit fits beside the broker or energy manager you already have.
Do you work with electric cooperatives and municipal utilities?
Yes. The audit tests each account against the tariff of whichever utility serves it, including cooperatives and municipal utilities, across the US and Canada.
Will the audit disrupt harvest?
No. The audit works from bills, meter data and tariffs obtained from the utilities. There is no site visit and no equipment to install.
Can you tell whether a site qualifies for an agricultural rate?
We compare each account's usage history with the eligibility tests in its utility's tariff. Only the utility's tariff decides, and no change is requested without your written approval. A free rate class check is a good place to start.
We just acquired several elevators. Is now a good time?
Often, yes. Acquired accounts carry forward the prior owner's rate classes and riders. The diversified agribusiness case above began with an audit after an acquisition.
What does it cost?
There is no upfront fee. The fee is usually 15% to 50% of refunds and verified savings, paid only when you receive them. Utilities never pay us. See pricing.
Do you audit propane or water?
No. Our audits cover electricity and natural gas. Water and other utility bills can be included in bill pay.
Sources
- US EIA, 2022 Manufacturing Energy Consumption Survey, Table 5.2: End uses of fuel consumption, grain and oilseed milling (NAICS 3112) fuel use, electricity for machine drive, natural gas and boiler fuel; shares calculated from the table.
- University of Nebraska-Lincoln CropWatch, 2023 Irrigation and Water Management data now available, reporting the USDA NASS survey figure of $3.3 billion in energy costs for pumping irrigation water in 2023.
- Georgia Power, Agriculture and Irrigation Rate Plans, eligibility tests for seasonal agricultural, agricultural process and irrigation off-peak schedules.
- Discovery Energy, diversified agribusiness case study, the audit results.
Find out what your bills should have cost.
Send one recent bill per site, or a list of accounts. We tell you where we expect findings before you sign anything. No upfront audit fee.