Natural gas bill audits for commercial and industrial companies
Gas bills turn metered volume into energy, apply a rate class and a delivery service, and often add a supplier's price. Errors in any step repeat every month. We test each one against the utility's tariff and the supply contract, for every account in scope, and recover what should not have been billed.
A natural gas bill audit is a review of 36 to 48 months of commercial or industrial gas bills against the utility's tariff, the meter and correction factors, and any supply contract. It finds volume conversions, rate classes and service types that were applied wrongly, files documented refund claims, and moves each account to the service it qualifies for.
01 / 07
Where commercial gas bills go wrong
A commercial gas bill converts metered volume into energy, applies a rate class and a delivery service, and in many states adds a supplier's commodity charge on top. Gas-intensive plants, from galvanizing and heat treating to food processing and grain drying, can carry large errors in each of those steps. Most leave the arithmetic correct; the problem is the factor, schedule or service type underneath.
Large gas users usually face two bills that both have to be right. US Energy Information Administration (EIA) data show how far the market has moved to transport service, where a supplier sells the gas and the utility only delivers it:
- 13.4%
- Share of US industrial natural gas deliveries in 2025 that the delivering utility also sold. The rest was delivered for the account of others: bought from a supplier and transported by the utility.
- 64.7%
- The same share for commercial deliveries in 2025. About a third of commercial gas was transported for others.
- $10.98 and $5.23
- Average 2025 US price per thousand cubic feet for gas sold by utilities to commercial and industrial customers, including delivery, commodity and demand charges.
02 / 07
What we test on every gas account
Every account in scope is tested, not a sample.
| What we test | What goes wrong | Where it matters most |
|---|---|---|
| Rate class | A site billed under a general-service schedule when its volume qualifies for a large-volume or industrial schedule. See rate misclassification. | Plants that added gas load |
| Sales or transport service | Sites that could buy gas from a supplier and pay the utility only for delivery, or sites set up for transport incorrectly. | States with gas supplier choice |
| Firm or interruptible | Interruptible service a site could use and never applied for, or firm charges on load that is interruptible. | Sites with backup fuel or flexible processes |
| Heat content (therm factor) | Volume converted to therms or dekatherms with the wrong heating value. | Every gas bill |
| Pressure correction | Missing or wrong pressure factor when gas is delivered above standard pressure. | Elevated-pressure services |
| Meter index and multiplier | A wrong index or correction factor after a meter or corrector exchange. See meter multiplier errors. | Large meters with volume correctors |
| Demand and contract quantities | Daily or seasonal demand charges billed above the contracted or measured quantity. | Large-volume and transport schedules |
| Balancing and penalties | Imbalance and operational flow order charges billed without matching the utility's or pipeline's notices. An operational flow order is an instruction from the pipeline or utility, usually in tight conditions, that limits how far a shipper's deliveries may differ from its use. | Transport customers in winter |
| Seasonal rates | Winter and summer rates applied outside the tariff dates. See seasonal rate errors. | Seasonal gas tariffs |
| Reads and classification | Estimated reads never reconciled, and accounts classified in a way that does not match how the site operates. See estimated reads. | Sites after a meter problem or account change |
03 / 07
How volume becomes a bill, and where the factors slip
Gas meters measure volume, usually in hundreds or thousands of cubic feet. Gas is billed in energy, usually therms or dekatherms. A therm is 100,000 British thermal units (Btu), and a dekatherm is ten therms. The utility converts one to the other with two factors:
- Heat content. The energy in each cubic foot varies with the gas in the pipe. The EIA puts the 2025 US average for gas delivered to consumers at 1,036 Btu per cubic foot, and state averages in the lower 48 ranged from 1,016 in Texas to 1,096 in Washington. Utilities apply a heating value for each billing period, and the wrong period's value, a stale default or a value from another district can be applied.
- Pressure. A meter measures gas at the pressure it is delivered. When a site takes gas above the tariff's standard pressure, the measured volume must be corrected upward to the standard base. A missing correction undercharges; a wrong or doubled correction overcharges. Volume correctors on large meters do this automatically, and they are reset or replaced during meter work.
Illustrative example, not a client result
A plant uses 1,000,000 cubic feet of gas in a month. At a heating value of 1,036 Btu per cubic foot, that is 10,360 therms. If the bill applies 1,060 instead, it shows 10,600 therms: 240 more, or 2.3%, on every therm-based charge, every month. Nothing on the bill looks wrong unless the heating value is checked against the utility's published value for that period.
04 / 07
Supply contracts and market prices
Where a supplier sells the gas, the bill should match the contract: the NYMEX price or index, the basis to the delivery point, the supplier's adder and any swing or balancing terms. We check each against the contract and against published prices. For how a delivered gas price is built, see natural gas: NYMEX and basis, and for the market, Henry Hub gas prices back to 1997.
Delivery capacity is now a cost question
In some metros, gas utilities are close to the limit of what they can deliver on the coldest day, which shows up as tighter rules for interruptible customers, more operational flow orders and new charges for large loads. Discovery tracks this in natural gas capacity outlooks for 48 U.S. metros, built from the utilities' own filings.
Who a gas audit suits
- Gas-intensive plants: furnaces, kilns, boilers, dryers and process heat. See steel and metals, food processing and agribusiness.
- Sites that added gas load and may now qualify for a large-volume or transport schedule.
- Portfolios in several states, where each utility sets its own thresholds and transport rules. See RNG producers and chemical distribution.
- Transport customers with balancing, imbalance or flow order charges each winter.
05 / 07
How the gas audit runs
The audit is an off-site review of bills, meter data, tariffs and contracts. There is no hardware, no site visit and no interruption to service.
Authorize
You sign a letter of authorization (LOA) and share one bill per site, or an account list with service addresses. We request billing history and meter data directly from each utility.
Test every account
We review 36 to 48 months of bills for every account in scope against the tariff in force at the time: rate class, service type, heating value, pressure and meter factors, demand and contract quantities, balancing and seasonal dates. Supplier invoices are tested against the contract.
Approve and file
Initial findings usually arrive in 30 to 60 days and are presented in a meeting. You approve each claim before it is filed, and we handle the utility conversations.
Recover and correct
Formal refunds or rate changes can take a further 60 to 120 days. The recoverable period is typically 1 to 5 years, set by each state and utility; see refund periods by state.
It helps to send supplier invoices and contracts for transport accounts, and to note which sites have interruptible service or backup fuel, and any meter, corrector or gas load changes in the last five years.
06 / 07
What you receive, and results on gas accounts
- A findings report separating one-time refunds, recurring savings and items that need more data.
- For each claim, the tariff sheet or rule it relies on and the calculation of what should have been billed.
- Copies of what is filed with the utility, its response, and proof of each refund as it posts.
The San Antonio account had been billed for years under a general-service schedule. The steel company had gas-intensive galvanizing and processing plants and an existing energy manager. At the RNG producer, the 13 sites were in Arizona, California, Michigan, Minnesota and North Carolina. Read the steel company case and the RNG producer case. Since 2000, recoveries have most often equaled 3% to 15% of annual utility spend; results vary and are not guaranteed.
How it fits with other services, and how it is priced
The audit can be engaged on its own. Where a site moves to transport service or a contract is renewing, energy procurement can follow on the corrected baseline, with any supplier commission disclosed up front. Bill pay and TaraBase reporting run on the same account inventory. The audit fee is contingency-based: no upfront fee, usually 15% to 50% of refunds and verified savings, paid only when you receive them. Start with a free rate class check or a 15-account pilot audit.
07 / 07
Questions buyers ask
What does a natural gas bill audit check?
Rate class, sales or transport service, firm or interruptible service, heat-content and pressure factors, meter index and correctors, demand and contract quantities, balancing charges, seasonal rates and the supply contract.
What is transport gas, and could we use it?
Transport service means a supplier sells the gas and the utility only delivers it. Eligibility depends on the state, the utility and the site's volume. An audit checks whether each site qualifies and whether it is set up correctly.
Can therm factors really be wrong?
Yes. The heating value and pressure factors that turn volume into billed energy are set by the utility and can be applied wrongly, especially after a meter or corrector change. A heating value off by about 2% changes every therm-based charge by about 2%.
Do you audit gas bills in regulated states?
Yes, in regulated and deregulated markets across the US and Canada.
Do you check the supplier's invoice as well as the utility bill?
Yes. Where a supplier sells the gas, we check the index or NYMEX price, basis, adder and swing or balancing terms against the contract and published prices.
How far back can gas refunds go?
We review 36 to 48 months of bills. The recoverable period is typically 1 to 5 years, set by each state and utility.
Sources
- US EIA, U.S. Natural Gas Prices (annual), 2025 commercial ($10.98) and industrial ($5.23) prices per thousand cubic feet; share of commercial (64.7%) and industrial (13.4%) deliveries included in prices.
- US EIA, Natural gas prices: definitions, sources and explanatory notes, prices cover onsystem sales only and include delivery, commodity and demand charges; the percentage of volume delivered represents sales, the rest being deliveries for the account of others.
- US EIA, Heat content of natural gas delivered to consumers, 2025 US average of 1,036 Btu per cubic foot; state values from 1,016 (Texas) to 1,096 (Washington) in the lower 48.
- US EIA, Energy conversion calculators, one therm equals 100,000 Btu.
Find out what your bills should have cost.
Send one recent bill per site, or a list of accounts. We tell you where we expect findings before you sign anything. No upfront audit fee.