Utility billing error library
The errors we find most often on commercial and industrial electric and gas bills. Each entry explains how the error happens, how to spot it and what can be recovered.
01 / 07
How to use this library
Most utility billing errors are not arithmetic mistakes. The bill adds up correctly, but one of the inputs behind it is wrong: the rate schedule, the meter multiplier, the seasonal dates, the account's classification, a capacity tag, or a reading that was estimated and never corrected. Nothing on the bill flags these problems, so they tend to repeat every month until someone tests the account against the tariff.
The entries below are grouped by where the error starts. Each one covers the root causes, what the error looks like on a bill, which sites are most exposed, a checklist you can run yourself, and how corrections and refunds work. How far back a refund can reach depends on the state and the utility's tariff; see refund periods by state.
02 / 07
Rate and tariff errors
The account is billed on the wrong terms, so every bill is wrong by a similar amount.
03 / 07
Meter and demand errors
The tariff is right, but the quantities it is applied to are wrong.
04 / 07
Market-set charges
Some charges are set by a few hours of a past summer and then billed all year.
05 / 07
Site changes and account inventory
The account no longer matches the site, because the site closed, idled or changed owners.
06 / 07
Where to start
- Plants and other demand-billed sites: start with rate misclassification, demand charge errors and meter multiplier errors.
- Sites in the PJM region (Pennsylvania, Ohio, Illinois, New Jersey, Maryland, Virginia and neighboring states): add capacity tag errors. Texas sites have a parallel issue in ERCOT 4CP.
- Manufacturers, processors and agricultural operations: check corporate classification for customer class and rider eligibility.
- Large networks of small accounts: start with estimated reads and closed-site accounts.
- After an acquisition, closure or consolidation: start with site changes and utility costs in acquisitions.
- If you are new to reading bills: begin with how to read a utility bill.
Discovery audits electricity and natural gas bills for multi-site organizations across the US and Canada, off-site and on contingency, testing each account for the errors in this library. Since 2000, recoveries have most often equaled 3% to 15% of annual utility spend, depending on the utilities and billing history. To test one site first, request a free rate class check, or read how utility bill audits work.
07 / 07
Questions buyers ask
Why do utility billing errors go undetected for years?
Utility billing systems do not flag their own configuration or classification errors, and internal teams rarely have the tariff and meter knowledge to spot them. The bills add up, so nothing looks wrong.
Can automated billing systems make mistakes?
Yes. Automation applies whatever configuration it was given, consistently. A wrong multiplier, outdated rate class or unreconciled estimate is repeated every month.
How far back can billing errors be refunded?
It depends on the state and the utility's tariff, and typically runs 1 to 5 years. Discovery reviews 36 to 48 months of bills to find what is recoverable. See refund periods by state.
Can I check for these errors myself?
Some, yes. Each entry includes a checklist. Errors that need the tariff, interval data or the utility's own calculations, such as rate eligibility, ratchets and capacity tags, are where an independent audit can add the most.
Does the library cover water and sewer bills?
No. The library and Discovery's audits cover electricity and natural gas. Water, sewer and other utilities can be included in utility bill pay, but they are not audited.
Sources
- PJM, 2026/2027 Base Residual Auction report, $329.17 per MW-day clearing price, the basis for the value of about $120,000 per megawatt-year.
Find out what your bills should have cost.
Send one recent bill per site, or a list of accounts. We tell you where we expect findings before you sign anything. No upfront audit fee.