Utility bill audit RFP checklist
A fair way to compare utility auditors: give every bidder the same information, test them on the same accounts, and compare net benefit after fees. Use it whether or not Discovery is on your list.
Run a utility bill audit RFP in five steps: send every bidder the same inventory, run a like-for-like pilot, normalize the fees, demand evidence, and test controls and independence. Score findings on accuracy and recoverability, and compare fees as net benefit over the same period and baseline.
01 / 06
Before you issue the RFP
Audit proposals are hard to compare because bidders define scope, savings and fees differently. The steps below remove those differences so the comparison is about skill and terms.
Settle three things internally first:
- Who owns the decision. Usually the CFO or controller, or operations leadership: someone who can sign a letter of authorization and accept engagement terms.
- What is in scope. Which sites, legal entities and utility types, and whether you want an audit only or also procurement, bill pay or reporting.
- What is already claimed. Whether a previous auditor or energy manager holds rights to findings on any accounts, and for how long.
02 / 06
The five steps
Send every bidder the same inventory
Give each bidder an identical data pack:
- Site and account inventory: legal entities, service addresses, utilities, meters, active and inactive accounts.
- Jurisdictions and rate classes for each account.
- Annual electric and natural gas spend, by site if possible.
- Supply contracts and their terms, including capacity and transmission treatment.
- How much bill history is available and whether a letter of authorization can be signed.
- Any previous audit: who, when, which accounts, and whether they hold rights to later findings.
Why it matters. Bidders who see different data produce estimates you cannot compare. Including inactive accounts matters because closed sites can keep billing, and listing prior audit coverage prevents disputes later over who found what.
A good answer looks like: a bidder that asks clarifying questions about your accounts, tells you what it needs to start (one bill per site and a signed authorization can be enough), and says where it expects to look first, without quoting a refund before reviewing anything.
Run a like-for-like pilot
Give finalists the same 15 or so representative accounts across at least three utilities, including your hardest industrial demand tariffs, gas accounts and any recently acquired sites. Require findings with tariff citations and a view on how much of each finding is recoverable.
Why it matters. A pilot turns claims into evidence on your own bills. Using the same accounts for every finalist is the only way to see who finds more, who finds it accurately, and who reads the tariff rather than running a generic checklist.
A good answer looks like: each finding names the account, the error, the tariff sheet or rule it relies on, the calculation of what should have been billed, the period affected, and whether it produces a refund, recurring savings or both. Accounts with no finding are reported as checked and correct, not left blank.
Normalize the fees
Compare net benefit after all fees using one baseline, one savings recognition date and the same recurring-savings period. Ask for the percentage, the base it applies to (refunds, credits, recurring savings, avoided costs), how many months of recurring savings count, the baseline method and any exclusions.
Why it matters. Contingency fees that look similar can differ widely in total cost. A lower percentage applied to 60 months of savings can cost more than a higher one applied to 12. Estimates and avoided costs inflate results if they count the same as refunds received.
A good answer looks like: a written fee definition with no upfront, minimum or pass-through charges you did not expect; a baseline agreed before work starts, with a stated method for adjusting it when usage, rates or operations change; and a clear rule for when a fee becomes payable, ideally only after you receive the money.
Demand evidence
Ask for a sample claim workpaper, a utility acceptance letter and proof of a posted refund or credit, plus two references from clients of similar size and industry.
Why it matters. A finding is not a recovery. Utilities can reject or modify a claim, the recoverable period may cover only part of the time an error existed, and some corrections apply only to future bills. Evidence of posted refunds shows the bidder can carry a finding through to money.
A good answer looks like: redacted documents that trace one issue from finding to filed claim to utility response to posted credit, and references who can confirm refunds received rather than findings reported. Published results should label refunds, recurring savings and estimates separately.
Test controls and independence
Confirm authorization limits, supplier compensation disclosure, data security and, if bill pay is bundled, funding custody and segregation of duties.
Why it matters. An auditor that also sells supply can have an incentive to steer toward a supplier switch, and an auditor with broad authority can change accounts you did not approve. Some states regulate broker compensation directly: New York's rules require brokers to disclose compensation.
A good answer looks like: every compensation source listed, including any supplier commissions; an audit-only scope available; nothing that changes an account, tariff, supplier or payment detail without your written approval; bill-pay funds held in an account you control; and a written policy for storing, accessing, retaining and deleting your bills and account data.
03 / 06
What to require back
Put these in the response template so every proposal answers them in the same place.
| Area | Ask for | Red flag |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | Every account or a sample? Which checks: rate class, tariff dates, meter multipliers, demand and ratchets, riders, corporate classification, capacity tags | Only large accounts reviewed, or checks described as "proprietary" with no list |
| Commodities | Electricity, natural gas, water and sewer: which are covered | Coverage claimed but no examples for a utility type |
| Pilot | Findings on the same 10 to 15 accounts, with tariff citations and a recoverability view | Dollar estimates with no account-level detail |
| Fees | Percentage, base (refunds, credits, recurring savings), recurring-savings period, baseline method, exclusions | Fees on estimated or avoided savings with no verification step |
| Evidence | Sample claim workpaper, utility acceptance letter, proof of a posted refund | Only summary claims or testimonials |
| Independence | All compensation sources, including supplier commissions; whether audit-only scope is available | Audit offered only with a supply contract |
| Authority | What the auditor may do without written approval (the answer should be nothing that changes an account) | Broad power of attorney with no approval step |
| Bill pay (if bundled) | Who holds funds, payment approval steps, reconciliation, late-payment handling, ERP export | Prefunding into an account you do not control, without reconciliation |
| Coverage | States and provinces served, including regulated ones | Coverage that stops at the states where the firm can sell supply |
| References | Two clients of similar size and industry | References that cannot confirm posted refunds |
| Data security | Storage, access, retention and deletion of bills and account data | No written policy |
04 / 06
How to compare proposals
- Score pilot findings on accuracy and recoverability, not count.
- Convert every fee proposal to net benefit over the same period and baseline.
- Separate one-time refunds from recurring savings and from estimates.
- Check references for posted refunds, not just findings reports.
- If one firm will also buy energy or pay bills, score those functions separately from audit skill.
Illustrative example, not a client result
Two bidders each find $100,000 in refunds and $40,000 a year in recurring savings on the pilot. Bidder A charges 30% of refunds and 12 months of savings: $42,000 in fees, leaving $98,000 over the first year. Bidder B charges 25% of refunds and 36 months of savings: $55,000 in fees over three years. Over the same three years, A's fees total $42,000, so B's lower percentage costs more. Run every proposal through the same calculation before you score price.
Ask each bidder to separate its own working time from steps that depend on your team and the utility. Gathering bills and authorizations depends on you; a utility's response to a claim can take anywhere from a very short time to two months or more.
For the questions to ask in interviews, see five questions to ask a utility bill auditor.
05 / 06
How Discovery answers this checklist
Discovery's own answers, for comparison.
- Scope
- Every account in scope, not a sample: rate class, tariff dates and seasons, meter multipliers, demand and ratchets, corporate classification, riders, reads and true-ups.
- Commodities
- Electricity and natural gas are audited. Water, sewer and other utilities can be included in bill pay, not audited.
- Pilot
- A 15-account pilot audit on representative accounts, including your hardest tariffs.
- Fees
- Contingency, usually 15% to 50% of refunds and verified savings, no upfront fee, paid only after you receive them. The fee typically applies to refunds plus the first year of savings, or the period your agreement sets, against a baseline agreed in writing.
- Evidence
- A findings report presented in a meeting, the tariff sheet and calculation behind each claim, copies of filings and utility responses, and proof of each refund as it posts.
- Independence
- Audit-only scope available. Utilities never pay us. Any supplier commission on procurement is disclosed before a contract is signed.
- Authority
- No claim is filed and no rate class, rider, tariff, supplier or payment detail changes without your written approval.
- Bill pay
- Payments from a funding account you control; Discovery schedules and reconciles. Most portfolios transition in 30 to 45 days.
- Coverage
- Regulated and deregulated markets across the US and Canada.
- Timing
- First findings in 30 to 60 days; refunds usually a further 60 to 120 days. Recoverable period typically 1 to 5 years, set by each state and utility.
Published, anonymized examples are in the case study library, with refunds and recurring savings labeled separately.
06 / 06
Questions buyers ask
How big should a pilot be?
Large enough to include each utility type and your most complex tariffs, small enough to finish quickly. Ten to fifteen accounts across three or more utilities is a common size.
Should we hire more than one contingency auditor?
Not on the same meters at the same time. Overlapping contingency auditors create disputes over who found what. Split by account set or run a pilot first.
How do we compare a contingency bid with a fixed-fee bid?
Estimate both as net benefit over the same period. A fixed fee is owed whatever is found; a contingency fee depends on results and on how the agreement defines them. See contingency vs fixed-fee audits.
How much bill history should bidders review?
Enough to cover the full recoverable period for each account, which is set by each state and utility. Discovery reviews 36 to 48 months of bills; the recoverable period is typically 1 to 5 years. See utility refunds by state.
Sources
- New York State Department of Public Service, Energy Broker and Energy Consultant Registration, registration under Public Service Law §66-t and disclosure of broker compensation.
Find out what your bills should have cost.
Send one recent bill per site, or a list of accounts. We tell you where we expect findings before you sign anything. No upfront audit fee.