Request a bill review
Discovery Energy ยท Contingency vs fixed fee

Contingency vs fixed-fee utility audits

The fee model decides who carries the risk of an audit that finds nothing, what the auditor is paid to do, and how much of the result you keep. Here is how the three common models compare, and what to read in any agreement before you sign.

A contingency utility audit charges nothing upfront and takes a percentage of refunds and verified savings; a fixed-fee audit charges a set price regardless of findings; a retainer pays for ongoing review time. Discovery Energy audits on contingency, usually 15% to 50%. Which model costs less depends on what the audit finds, so the contract terms that define the fee matter more than the label.

ContingencyFixed feeRetainer
Upfront costNoneSet priceRecurring
If nothing is foundYou owe nothingFee still dueFee still due
Who carries the riskThe auditorYouYou
When you payAfter refunds and savings arrive, under the agreed termsOn delivery of the scope, or by milestoneMonthly or per bill, account or meter
Auditor's incentiveFind and recover moneyFinish the scopeSpend the hours
Budget approval neededRarelyYesYes
Total cost if findings are largeHigherLowerDepends on term
Watch forBaseline definition, fee periodNarrow scope, samplingUnclear deliverables

02 / 06

How each model works

Contingency

The auditor is paid a share of what it recovers and saves: refunds or bill credits for past overcharges, and lower bills after an account is corrected. The share applies to refunds plus a set period of recurring savings, after which the savings are entirely yours. Because the fee comes out of money that would not otherwise exist, it rarely needs a budget line.

The model is common outside the energy industry too. US federal agencies procure recovery audits of their own payments this way. The Department of Veterans Affairs' financial policy, for example, states that its recovery audit contracts use a contingency fee based on a negotiated percentage of funds certified as recovered, and that the obligation is recorded only once the amount collected is certified.

Fixed fee

You pay a set price for a defined scope: a number of accounts, a look-back period and a deliverable. The cost is known in advance and does not grow with the findings. The risk sits with you, and the auditor's job is to complete the scope, so how the scope is written decides how thorough the work is. Fixed-fee scopes sometimes test a sample of large accounts and skip the small ones where errors accumulate.

Retainer or recurring fee

A monthly amount, or a rate per bill, account or meter, for ongoing review. It suits continuous bill checking more than a one-time recovery. Ask exactly which checks run every cycle and which ran once at set-up.

Hybrids

Some agreements pair a contingency share with separate charges, for example for data preparation. "No recovery, no fee" then applies only to the contingency part. Ask for every possible charge in writing.

03 / 06

A worked comparison

Illustrative example, not a client result

An audit of a 40-site portfolio finds $60,000 in refunds and corrects accounts worth $40,000 a year in lower bills. Under a contingency agreement at 30% of refunds plus the first year of savings, the fee is $30,000, paid as the money arrives. The company nets $70,000 in the first year and keeps the full $40,000 every year after. Under a $25,000 fixed fee for the same scope, the company nets $75,000 in the first year. If the audit had found nothing, the contingency client would owe nothing; the fixed-fee client would still owe $25,000.

The example shows the real trade. Contingency costs more when findings are large and nothing when they are not. A fixed fee is cheaper only if you are confident the audit will find enough to cover it, and only if the scope is broad enough to find it.

When each model fits

Contingency fits when

  • Accounts have never been independently audited, so findings are uncertain.
  • There is no budget for an audit, or approving one would take months.
  • You want every account tested, including small ones.
  • You want the auditor to file and follow claims through to payment.

Fixed fee or retainer fits when

  • Your policy does not allow fees tied to recoveries.
  • You want a defined review, such as acquisition diligence, with no share of future savings.
  • You want ongoing bill checking, priced per bill, more than a historical recovery.

04 / 06

Three terms to read in any agreement

  1. How the savings baseline is set and adjusted.
  2. How long recurring savings count toward the fee.
  3. How refunds, credits, avoided costs and estimates are treated.

Questions to ask before you sign

Is every account audited, or a sample?

Sampling large accounts leaves the small ones, where errors build up unnoticed, untested.

How far back does the audit look?

The recoverable period is set by each state and utility, typically 1 to 5 years. See utility refunds by state.

When is the fee invoiced?

On refunds and credits actually received, or on projected savings. Payment should follow receipt.

What if a credit is reversed?

The agreement should say whether the fee is refunded if a utility later reverses a credit.

Do changes we make ourselves count?

Some agreements charge on any saving in scope, even one your own team found or made.

Who files and approves claims?

You should approve every claim and account change in writing before it is filed.

Are there any other charges?

Data preparation, set-up or early termination fees, and any clause that accelerates future fees on default.

05 / 06

Common mistakes

  • Comparing percentages instead of definitions. A lower rate on a long fee period, or on estimated savings, can cost more than a higher rate on refunds and one year of verified savings.
  • Leaving the baseline vague. If the baseline is not agreed in writing before work starts, every later rate change becomes an argument.
  • Buying a narrow fixed scope to save money. The cheapest scope is often the one that skips the accounts with the errors.
  • Ignoring what the fee covers. Claim filing, follow-up with the utility and correcting accounts going forward should be in the price, not extras.

How Discovery fits

Discovery's utility bill audits are contingency-based, and audit fees stay contingency-based throughout an engagement. We do not offer fixed-fee audits, so if your policy requires one, we are not the right fit for that part of the work.

  • No audit fee, retainer or setup charge. The fee is usually 15% to 50% of qualifying refunds, credits and verified savings, paid only after you receive them.
  • The rate depends on the size of the accounts and on whether Discovery also manages other parts of your energy program.
  • The fee typically applies to refunds plus the first year of savings, or the period your agreement sets. Savings after that are entirely yours.
  • Savings are measured against a baseline agreed in writing before work starts, with rules for how it adjusts if usage, rates or operations change.
  • If we find nothing, you owe nothing and receive documentation that your accounts were billed correctly.

Since 2000, recoveries have most often equaled 3% to 15% of annual utility spend, depending on the utilities and billing history. To test the process first, ask for a 15-account pilot audit on representative accounts, including your hardest tariffs. See pricing and independence and compensation.

06 / 06

Questions buyers ask

Is a contingency audit more expensive?

It can cost more in total if findings are large, but it carries no budget risk and no cost if nothing is found. A fixed fee is predictable but is owed regardless of results.

What contingency percentage is typical?

Discovery's fee is usually 15% to 50% of refunds and verified savings. Compare what the percentage applies to and for how long, not only the rate.

Do we share savings forever?

No. A contingency fee should apply to refunds and a defined period of recurring savings. At Discovery that is typically refunds plus the first year of savings, or the period your agreement sets.

What happens if the audit finds nothing?

Under a contingency agreement, you owe nothing. Discovery also provides documentation that your accounts were billed correctly.

Who keeps the recovered money?

You do, less the agreed contingency fee.

Can we try a contingency audit on part of the portfolio first?

Yes. Discovery offers a 15-account pilot audit on 15 representative accounts, or a free rate class check.

Sources

  1. US Department of Veterans Affairs, Financial Policy, Chapter 30: Overpayment Audit Recoveries, recovery audit contracts paid on a contingency-fee basis from funds certified as recovered, with the obligation recorded once collections are certified.

Find out what your bills should have cost.

Send one recent bill per site, or a list of accounts. We tell you where we expect findings before you sign anything. No upfront audit fee.