Request a bill review
Discovery Energy ยท Industries

Utility audits for private equity portfolio companies

Utility spend is a real cost line that almost nobody at a mid-market portfolio company owns, and every change of ownership adds new errors to it. Discovery audits it on contingency, from diligence through exit, without capital spending, site visits or management time taken from the value-creation plan.

Discovery Energy Utility Audits is an independent, contingency-based utility bill audit firm that has worked with multi-site companies across the US and Canada since 2000. For private equity portfolio companies, it audits electricity and natural gas bills against the utilities' tariffs, recovers refunds for past overcharges, corrects rates going forward and keeps accounts clean through add-ons and exit, with no upfront fee: it is paid a share of refunds and verified savings only when the company receives them.

01 / 13

Why utility spend is a value-creation lever in private equity

Sponsors buy companies to run them better. Most value-creation plans cover pricing, procurement, labor, footprint and working capital. Utilities rarely get a line of their own, even though for a manufacturer, food processor, distributor or cold-storage operator they can be one of the largest controllable costs after materials and people.

It sits in the P&L where it hurts margin

Plant electricity and gas usually sit in cost of goods sold, so they show up in gross margin. Offices, branches, warehouses and service locations carry their utilities in SG&A. Either way, every dollar of overbilling comes straight out of EBITDA, and every dollar corrected goes straight back in, with no change to volume, price or headcount.

Nobody owns it

At a mid-market company, utility bills are typically paid by accounts payable, coded to a site and approved by a plant or branch manager who checks that the amount looks normal. Nobody is reading the tariff. Nobody is checking whether the rate class still fits the load, whether a rider is optional, or whether the meter multiplier is right. Energy brokers, where one exists, buy supply; they do not usually audit the utility's delivery charges. The result is that errors can run for years without anyone noticing, because the bill is paid on time and looks like last month's.

It gets worse through ownership changes

Every acquisition moves accounts to a new owner. Utilities may re-set them up under the new legal entity, sometimes on a default rate. Classifications tied to the seller's business stop matching how the site runs. Supply contracts expire or roll to default pricing because the renewal date sat in someone's inbox at the seller. Bills go to an old address, autopay stops and late fees follow. A sponsor that buys a platform and three add-ons has inherited four sets of these problems in four years.

Prices have been rising

The cost of leaving the line alone has gone up. According to the US Energy Information Administration, the average retail price of electricity rose from 10.59 to 13.37 cents per kilowatt-hour for commercial customers between 2020 and 2025, about 26%, and from 6.67 to 8.51 cents for industrial customers, about 28%. A billing error that is a percentage of the bill grows with the bill.

02 / 13

Why the contingency model fits a PE hold

No capital spending
An audit corrects billing. It needs no equipment, no project and no capex approval.
No upfront fee
Discovery is paid a share of refunds and verified savings, usually 15% to 50%, only when the company receives them. A 15-account pilot is available.
No management distraction
The work is off-site: bills, interval meter data and tariffs. There is no hardware, no site visit and no production interruption. The company's main tasks are signing a letter of authorization and sending a list of accounts.
Fits the 100-day plan
First findings usually arrive in 30 to 60 days. Refunds usually follow in a further 60 to 120 days.
Independent
Utilities never pay Discovery. The audit can be engaged on its own. Any supplier commission on procurement is disclosed up front, and no account is changed without the company's written approval.

For a comparison of fee structures, read contingency versus fixed-fee utility audits. For detail on fees, see pricing and independence.

03 / 13

Utilities across the deal lifecycle

Utility work is cheapest and most valuable when it starts before close and follows the company to exit. Each stage has its own risks.

Pre-LOI and diligence

The goal is to know what the cost base really is and whether any utility issues will surprise the buyer after close. Ask for 24 to 36 months of bills for the largest sites and an accounts payable vendor history for every utility and supplier. Red flags to look for:

  • Estimated reads. Repeated estimated bills mean the utility has not read the meter, and a large catch-up bill may follow. See estimated reads.
  • Late fees, disconnection notices and deposits. These point to weak accounts payable processes and can mean the utility will ask a new owner for a security deposit.
  • Accounts in the seller's name, or in a parent's name. Common in carve-outs. Each one must move or be covered by a transition arrangement.
  • Expiring supply contracts. In deregulated markets, an account with no contract usually falls to the utility's default or provider-of-last-resort service, which may cost more. Check expiration dates, volume limits, early-termination terms and assignment or change-of-control clauses.
  • Demand ratchets. A demand ratchet is a minimum demand charge set by a past peak, usually a share of the highest demand over a period the tariff defines. A site that has reduced load, or plans to, may keep paying for its old peak.
  • Pending rate cases. A rate case is a utility's formal request to its state regulator to change rates. Check the main utilities' dockets: an approved increase changes the forward cost model.
  • Unusual swings in cost per unit. A site whose cost per kilowatt-hour or per therm differs sharply from similar sites may be on the wrong rate class.

Signing to close

Utilities are a closing-mechanics issue as much as a cost issue. Build the account list, decide which legal entity will hold each account, and ask each utility what a change of account holder triggers: a new deposit, a credit check, a reset payment history or a move to a default rate. Plan new letters of authorization so the new owner, and its advisers, can get billing data on day one.

In a carve-out, map every utility service the business uses. Look for shared meters, where a carved-out building is served through a meter in the seller's name; accounts that stay with the seller and are recharged under a transition services agreement (TSA); and supply contracts that cover both businesses. Each needs a plan and a date: separate service, submetering or a defined recharge method, and an exit from the TSA before it expires.

The first 100 days

Confirm the account inventory against what accounts payable actually paid, fix payment routing, and start the audit. Refund look-back periods are set by each state and utility, and some are counted back from when a claim is filed, so each month of delay can put older overcharges out of reach. The 100-day plan below sets out the stages.

The hold period

Once accounts are clean, the work becomes keeping them that way: monitoring bills each month, managing supply contracts, paying bills on time and reporting cost and emissions by site. Where the sponsor's structure and the contracts allow, portfolio companies with sites in the same markets can be grouped for energy procurement. Each company still signs its own contracts.

Add-on acquisitions

In a buy-and-build strategy, each add-on brings new utilities, states, rate structures and contracts. Running the same integration steps on every add-on, against one account inventory, keeps the platform's cost base clean as it grows. The playbook is set out below.

Exit readiness

A buyer's diligence team will look at the same things listed above. A company that can hand over a documented, audited utility baseline, accounts in the right names, contracts with known terms and clean emissions data gives the buyer fewer reasons to adjust the price.

04 / 13

Utility diligence data-request checklist

Add these items to the data room request list. Ask early: utilities and suppliers can take weeks to produce records.

Account inventory

Every electricity, natural gas, water and sewer account: utility, account and meter numbers, service address, rate class and the legal entity on the account.

Bills

24 to 36 months of bills for the largest sites, and at least 12 months for the rest. PDF copies show charges that summary spreadsheets leave out.

Accounts payable history

12 to 24 months of payments to every utility and energy supplier, to catch accounts missing from the seller's list.

Supply contracts

Every electricity and gas supply agreement with term, price structure, expiration, volume bands, early-termination fees and assignment or change-of-control clauses.

Interval and demand data

Interval meter data or 12 months of peak demand for large sites, to test rate class fit and any demand ratchet.

Deposits and payment status

Security deposits held by utilities, past-due balances, late fees and any disconnection notices in the last 24 months.

Shared and master meters

In a carve-out, any service shared with the seller, and how the cost is split today.

Planned changes

Sites to be closed, expanded, consolidated or re-tooled. Load changes affect rate class, demand charges and contract volumes. See utility accounts when sites change.

Emissions data

Any existing Scope 1 and Scope 2 inventory, the method used and the base year, if the company reports one.

05 / 13

A 100-day utility plan

  1. Days 1 to 15: authorization and inventory

    The portfolio company signs a letter of authorization so Discovery can request billing data from each utility. Discovery builds the account inventory from accounts payable history and the seller's list, and flags past-due balances and disconnection notices.

  2. Days 15 to 30: payment routing and contracts

    Confirm every bill reaches the right place and is paid on time. Collect supply contracts and record expiration dates. Identify accounts still in the seller's name and plan their transfer.

  3. Days 30 to 60: audit and first findings

    Discovery reviews 36 to 48 months of bills against the tariffs, meter data and contracts: rate class, riders, meter multipliers, demand, seasonal dates and capacity and transmission tags. First findings usually arrive in 30 to 60 days.

  4. Days 60 to 100: claims and corrections

    With the company's written approval, Discovery files refund claims with the utilities and requests rate and account corrections. Refunds usually follow in a further 60 to 120 days.

  5. Day 100 and beyond: baseline and ongoing control

    Record the corrected cost baseline by site. Decide whether to add procurement, bill pay, cost allocation and TaraBase reporting on the same account inventory. A bill pay transition usually takes 30 to 45 days.

06 / 13

Through the hold: one account inventory per company

An audit fixes what is wrong today. Bills change every month, so the savings last only if someone keeps watching. Discovery can run five services for a portfolio company on one account inventory, so each new site or add-on is added once and every service sees it.

  • Utility bill audits and overcharge recovery: past errors refunded, rates corrected, new bills checked.
  • Energy procurement: supply contracts timed and aligned across sites in deregulated markets, with any supplier commission disclosed up front. Read audit versus procurement for the difference.
  • Utility bill pay: bills paid on time from one process, which stops late fees and protects payment history.
  • Cost allocation: utility cost coded to the right site, entity and general ledger account, which matters when a platform has several legal entities.
  • TaraBase reporting: savings, usage, contracts and Scope 2 data by site, in one place that a CFO or operating partner can read.

Add-on integration playbook

Run the same steps on every add-on, ideally starting before close:

  1. Request bills, accounts payable history and supply contracts in diligence, using the checklist above.
  2. Add the add-on's accounts to the platform's account inventory, with the legal entity on each.
  3. Sign a letter of authorization covering the new accounts.
  4. Move payment routing into the platform's bill pay process before the first bill is missed.
  5. Audit the inherited accounts and file refund claims within the look-back period.
  6. Align supply contract end dates with the platform's contracts and confirm the energy adviser is licensed in the new states.
  7. Add the sites to cost allocation, reporting and the emissions inventory.

For the full checklist, read utility costs in acquisitions: what to check after the deal closes.

07 / 13

Exit readiness and ESG data for LPs

What a buyer will want to see

  • A documented utility baseline by site, with audited rate classes and the savings already captured.
  • Every account in the correct legal entity, with no past-due balances or open disputes.
  • Supply contracts with known terms, and no auto-renewal, change-of-control or early-termination clause that will surprise the buyer.
  • Scope 2 emissions data built from actual bills, with a clear method and history.

Emissions data starts with utility bills

The US Environmental Protection Agency defines Scope 2 emissions as indirect greenhouse gas emissions associated with the purchase of electricity, steam, heat or cooling. The quantities behind that number, kilowatt-hours and therms by site and month, are on the utility bills. A company whose bills are already collected and checked for an audit has most of the raw data for its Scope 2 inventory. Read Scope 2 data from utility bills.

LPs increasingly ask GPs for this data. The ESG Data Convergence Initiative (EDCI), a private-markets effort to standardize ESG metrics, lists Scope 1 and Scope 2 greenhouse gas emissions among its core metrics, alongside the share of renewable energy used. Scope 3 is listed as non-core. EDCI reports more than 400 general and limited partner members and a benchmark covering about 10,000 portfolio companies. For a GP that reports to EDCI or answers similar LP questionnaires, accurate site-level energy data from each portfolio company makes the reporting faster and more defensible. TaraBase reporting holds that data per company.

08 / 13

Which portfolio companies benefit most

Any company with meaningful utility spend can have billing errors. The largest findings tend to come from companies with many sites, many utilities or energy-intensive operations.

Portfolio company typeWhy utilities matterRead more
Manufacturing and industrialLarge motor, compressed air and process loads; demand charges and ratchets; primary-voltage and interruptible ratesManufacturing
Chemicals and chemical distributionMany sites across utilities and states, often assembled by acquisitionChemical distribution
Food and protein processingRefrigeration, boilers and seasonal rates; gas and electricity both significantFood processing
AgribusinessGrain handling, milling and drying; seasonal loads and agricultural rate optionsAgribusiness
Steel, metals and metal finishingFurnaces and high-demand loads; large gas accounts with transport optionsSteel and metals
Logistics, cold storage and warehousingMany locations; refrigeration and 24/7 operation in cold storageCold storage and logistics, Warehousing and distribution
Plastics, paper and packagingContinuous process loads, dryers, extruders and chillersPlastics, Paper and packaging
Renewable natural gasProduction and fueling sites across many states and utilitiesRNG producers
Multi-location servicesDozens or hundreds of small accounts that nobody reviews one by oneMulti-site energy management

09 / 13

What we have found after acquisitions

Diversified agribusiness$117,412Refunds from an audit after an acquisition of grain, flour and soybean operations in 3 states. Five issues: rate, rider and stuck-meter errors, plus about $120,000 a year saved by opting out of a rider. Read the case.
Industrial services provider, 103 facilitiesLate fees endedMore than half the sites paid late fees every month after an acquisition. Late fees were eliminated, and 100% of spend appeared in one dashboard, once audit, procurement and bill pay ran on one account inventory. Read the case.
Global chemical distributor$500,000+ a year215+ facilities, 1,000+ accounts and 87 providers in the US and Canada, growing by acquisition. $500,000+ a year saved and $300,000+ in refunds. Read the case.

Savings by client

Total documented savings for multi-site clients in sectors that private equity commonly owns:

Industrial equipment and precision medical, 56 locations$1,778,902
Chemical and ingredients distribution, 180 locations$1,461,071
Specialty chemical supplier, 28 locations$1,375,324
Specialty chemical additives$1,169,175
Logistics and industrial solutions, 200 locations$772,968
Metal coating and galvanizing, 60 locations$421,845

More results, with the errors behind them, are in the case studies.

10 / 13

How sponsors and portfolio companies engage

  1. Start with one company or a pilot

    A sponsor can start with one portfolio company, or with a 15-account pilot audit at one company, to see the findings before going further. A free rate class check is also available.

  2. Each company engages on its own

    Each portfolio company signs its own letter of authorization and gets its own findings and its own savings baseline. Refunds and savings stay with the business that earned them, which keeps each company's numbers clean for reporting, lenders and exit.

  3. Roll out company by company

    A portfolio-wide rollout runs one company at a time, in the order the sponsor sets, often starting with the largest utility spend or the most recent acquisition. Talk to us about a portfolio-wide rollout.

  4. Add services on the same inventory

    Any company can add procurement, bill pay, cost allocation and TaraBase reporting to the audit, all on one account inventory. The audit can also be engaged on its own.

Discovery has audited tens of thousands of electricity and natural gas accounts across the US and Canada. Water, sewer and other utility bills can be included in bill pay. Company background is on the facts page.

11 / 13

How can private equity firms cut utility costs across portfolio companies?

The fastest route is the same at every company in the fund, run on a common playbook:

  1. Audit every account on contingency

    Recover refunds for errors inherited from previous owners and correct rates going forward, with no capital spending and no upfront fee. Each company signs its own letter of authorization and keeps its own savings baseline.

  2. Buy supply as a portfolio where markets allow

    Run one RFP across every deregulated state the companies operate in, with aligned end dates. See multi-state electricity RFPs and natural gas procurement.

  3. Stop late fees and lost bills

    Centralize bill pay so acquired sites do not keep paying the seller's way, and code every bill to the company's GL. See bill payment and data capture.

  4. Manage capacity and demand

    In PJM, capacity tags and summer peaks now drive a large share of the bill. See PJM capacity charges.

  5. Report it once

    Hold every company's accounts, contracts and savings in one platform, with Scope 1 and 2 data ready for LP reporting. See TaraBase.

A sponsor can start with one portfolio company or a 15-account pilot and roll the program out company by company.

12 / 13

Questions an operating partner should ask a portfolio CFO

  1. What did we spend on electricity, gas and water last year, by site?
  2. Who reviews utility bills against the tariff, not just for approval?
  3. How many utility accounts do we have, and does the list match what accounts payable paid?
  4. Are any accounts still in a seller's or former parent's name?
  5. Did we pay any late fees or receive disconnection notices in the last 12 months?
  6. When does each supply contract expire, and what happens if it lapses?
  7. When were our rate classes last checked against current load?
  8. Has any site's load changed since it was acquired, closed a line or added a shift?
  9. Do we have site-level energy and Scope 2 data the sponsor can report to LPs?

Questions to ask any utility audit provider

  1. How is the fee set, and is it paid only from refunds and savings actually received?
  2. How many months of bills do you review, and how far back can refunds go in our states?
  3. Do you check rate classes, riders, meter multipliers, demand and capacity tags?
  4. Do utilities or suppliers pay you anything, and are commissions disclosed?
  5. Will you change any account without our written approval?
  6. Can each portfolio company engage separately, with its own baseline?
  7. Can you also handle procurement, bill pay and reporting, and can we buy the audit alone?
  8. How will savings be verified and reported?

A fuller list is in the utility audit RFP checklist.

13 / 13

Questions buyers ask

Fees, results, and how an audit fits beside the broker or energy manager you already have.

How can a PE portfolio company reduce utility costs without capex?

Start with a utility bill audit. It checks every account against the utility's tariff for errors such as the wrong rate class, optional riders, meter multiplier errors and demand billing mistakes, and recovers refunds for past overcharges. It needs no equipment or project. Procurement and bill pay can follow on the same account inventory.

What does it cost a portfolio company?

Nothing upfront. Discovery is paid a share of refunds and verified savings, usually 15% to 50%, only when the company receives them. A 15-account pilot is available.

How much management time does it take during the 100-day plan?

Very little. The company signs a letter of authorization and provides an account list or recent bills. Discovery requests the billing history from the utilities and reviews it off-site. There are no site visits, and no account is changed without written approval.

How much can an audit typically find?

Since 2000, recoveries have most often equaled 3% to 15% of annual utility spend, depending on the utilities and the billing history. Results vary, and some audits find less. First findings usually arrive in 30 to 60 days.

Should utilities be part of diligence, or wait until after close?

Both. In diligence, request bills, accounts payable history and supply contracts to check the cost base and spot red flags such as estimated reads, late fees, expiring contracts and demand ratchets. The audit itself starts once the new owner can sign a letter of authorization, ideally in the first 100 days.

Are refunds counted in EBITDA?

Refunds are typically non-recurring and may be treated as one-time items in a quality-of-earnings analysis. Recurring rate corrections lower future bills and lift run-rate EBITDA. The company's accountants decide how each item is treated.

Can you work across the whole portfolio?

Yes, company by company. Each portfolio company signs its own letter of authorization and keeps its own findings and savings baseline. A sponsor can start with one company or a pilot and roll out from there.

How do you handle add-on acquisitions?

Each add-on's accounts are added to the platform's account inventory, authorized, moved into bill pay, audited within the refund look-back period and brought into procurement and reporting. The same steps run on every add-on.

Can the audit data support our ESG reporting to LPs?

Yes. Utility bills hold the electricity and gas quantities behind Scope 2 emissions. TaraBase reporting holds usage, cost and Scope 2 data by site for each company, which supports frameworks such as EDCI that include Scope 1 and 2 emissions as core metrics.

How can private equity firms cut utility costs across portfolio companies?

Audit every electricity and gas account at each company on contingency to recover inherited overcharges and correct rates, buy supply as a portfolio in deregulated states, centralize bill pay to stop late fees after add-ons, manage capacity and demand charges, and report savings and Scope 2 data from one platform. Discovery Energy runs this playbook with no capital spending and no upfront audit fee.

Sources

  1. US Energy Information Administration, Electric Power Monthly, Table 5.3: Average Price of Electricity to Ultimate Customers, annual commercial and industrial prices for 2020 and 2025.
  2. ESG Data Convergence Initiative, Metrics, Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions and renewable energy share as core metrics; Scope 3 as non-core.
  3. ESG Data Convergence Initiative, home page, 400+ general and limited partner members and a benchmark of about 10,000 portfolio companies.
  4. US EPA Center for Corporate Climate Leadership, Scope 1 and Scope 2 Inventory Guidance, definition of Scope 2 emissions.

Find out what your bills should have cost.

Send one recent bill per site, or a list of accounts. We tell you where we expect findings before you sign anything. No upfront audit fee.