Request a bill review
Discovery Energy ยท Audit vs procurement

Utility bill audit vs energy procurement

One looks back and fixes how you were billed; the other looks forward at what you buy. Companies often hire one and assume it covers the other. Here is what each does, where each applies, and why the order matters.

A utility bill audit is backward-looking: it tests whether historical and current bills were calculated correctly and recovers overcharges. Energy procurement is forward-looking: it sets the price and terms of future supply. They solve different problems, so a good supply contract does not fix past billing errors, and fixing past bills does not secure future pricing.

Utility bill auditEnergy procurement
Question it answersWere we billed correctly?What should we pay for future supply?
Time directionPast and present billsFuture contracts
Where it appliesEvery market, regulated and deregulatedOnly where customer choice exists
What it tests or setsThe utility's application of its tariff: rate class, riders, demand, meters, classificationsThe supply price, product and term
What it changesRate class, riders, meters, classifications, refundsSupplier, product, term, timing
Who is on the other sideThe utilityCompeting retail suppliers
Data it needs36 to 48 months of bills, meter data and tariffs, under a letter of authorizationUsage history, current contracts and expiration dates
Typical resultRefunds plus lower recurring billsLower or more predictable supply cost
Main risk to youLittle, on contingency: no findings, no feeMarket timing: a price locked at the wrong moment
Typical feeContingency on resultsMonthly fee or supplier commission

02 / 06

Why one does not cover the other

Every commercial bill has a delivery side, set by the utility's tariff, and a supply side. Procurement can change only the supply side, and only where the law allows a choice of supplier. Even then, as the US Energy Information Administration (EIA) notes, the distribution utility still delivers the energy and charges for that service.

An audit tests the parts procurement never touches: whether the account is on the right rate schedule, whether demand was read and billed correctly, whether a meter multiplier matches the equipment, whether riders apply, and whether the account is classified correctly for rates and riders. In regulated markets, where the utility also sells the energy, the audit covers the whole bill.

Illustrative example, not a client result

A plant was set up on a general-service schedule when it opened and grew into a large-power load. Its broker runs a strong supply RFP and cuts the supply rate by 0.4 cents per kWh. The delivery charges are still calculated on the wrong schedule, costing the plant more each month than the new contract saves, and the supply bids were priced against a load profile and class that were never checked. An audit moves the account to the correct schedule, claims a refund for the recoverable period, and gives the next RFP an accurate baseline.

Where each applies

Audits apply everywhere a company pays a utility bill. Competitive supply does not. EIA reports that 19 states and the District of Columbia allow at least some commercial and industrial customers to choose a competitive electricity supplier, and that customers of investor-owned utilities in the ERCOT region of Texas must choose a retail provider. For natural gas, large commercial and industrial customers have long been able to buy supply separately from delivery, typically on a utility transportation schedule.

Procurement providers are also limited by licensing. Pennsylvania licenses brokers and marketers as electric generation suppliers, Texas requires brokers to register with its Public Utility Commission, and Ohio requires power brokers and aggregators to be certified. A provider licensed in a few states cannot buy for the rest of your sites, and regulated-state accounts are often the least reviewed because no supplier competition draws attention to them.

03 / 06

Which comes first

Usually the audit. If an account is on the wrong rate class or misclassified, that error becomes part of the baseline used to evaluate supply bids. Correcting it first means suppliers price an accurate load and the savings you report are measured against a verified number.

The exception is timing. If a supply contract expires in the next few months, do not let it roll onto default pricing while the audit runs. Run both in parallel: the audit works off-site from bills and tariffs and does not hold up a purchase, and its findings can feed the next renewal.

When each fits on its own

Start with an audit when

  • Bills have never been independently reviewed against the tariff.
  • Sites have grown, shrunk, added equipment or changed hands.
  • Most sites are in regulated states.
  • You already have a broker but nobody tests delivery charges.

Start with procurement when

  • Contracts in deregulated markets are about to expire.
  • Sites are on default service with no contract at all.
  • Finance needs budget certainty for the next fiscal year.
  • Natural gas sites qualify for transportation service but buy from the utility.

04 / 06

Questions to ask a provider that offers both

Can the audit be bought on its own?

An audit should never require you to move procurement.

How is each service paid?

Ask for the audit fee and any supplier commission separately, disclosed before anything is signed.

Do audit findings depend on the supplier?

They should not. An audit tests the utility's billing under its tariff, whoever supplies the energy.

Which states can you buy in?

Compare the provider's licensing footprint with your site list.

Are delivery charges tested against the tariff?

Reviewing a supplier invoice is not the same as testing the utility's rate class, demand and riders.

Common mistakes

  • Assuming the broker audits. Brokers focus on supply price, not tariff application.
  • Assuming "fixed" fixes everything. Delivery charges are always separate, and capacity or transmission can pass through. See contract structures.
  • Buying on an unchecked baseline. A wrong rate class or meter multiplier carries straight into the bids.
  • Treating refunds and savings as the same thing. Refunds end once paid. Correct account setup and competitive supply pricing keep working every month.

05 / 06

How Discovery fits

Discovery offers both because they depend on each other, and each can be engaged alone. See utility bill audits and energy procurement.

  • Audits are contingency-based: usually 15% to 50% of refunds and verified savings, paid only when you receive them.
  • Procurement is paid by a fixed monthly fee or a supplier commission, your choice, disclosed before any contract is signed. Utilities never pay us.
  • No account, tariff or supplier changes without your written approval.

For a multi-state renewable natural gas producer, Discovery ran both at once. The audit recovered $3,959,202 in one-time refunds across 10 states and cut ongoing bills by $187,455 a month. On the buying side, a competitive RFP for one New Jersey electric account saves an average of $167,000 a month, and correcting the transport gas setup at 13 sites is expected to save more than $50,000 a month. No single review of one state, one utility or one contract would have found all of it. Read the RNG producer case study.

06 / 06

Questions buyers ask

Which should come first?

Usually the audit. If an account is on the wrong rate class or misclassified, that error becomes part of the baseline used to evaluate supply bids.

Does procurement work in regulated states?

Competitive supply is only available where the state allows customer choice. Audits apply everywhere, regulated or not.

Our broker says it reviews our bills. Is that an audit?

Not necessarily. Many reviews check supplier invoices or flag unusual bills. An audit tests each account against the utility's tariff, rate class, meter set-up and riders, and files claims for what was overbilled.

Can we keep our broker and still have an audit?

Yes. The audit is a records review that runs alongside existing contracts. Many clients keep their incumbent for procurement and use Discovery for tariff-level validation.

Does an audit change our supplier?

No. An audit does not depend on who supplies your energy, and you stay with your utility unless you approve a separate change.

Sources

  1. US EIA, Can customers choose their electricity supplier?, delivery charged by the distribution utility; ERCOT customers must choose a provider.
  2. US EIA, Today in Energy (November 1, 2019), 19 states and DC allowing some commercial and industrial customers to choose competitive retail power marketers.
  3. US EIA, Natural gas customer choice programs, large commercial and industrial consumers buying gas separately from other services.
  4. Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission, Electric Generation Supplier application resources, broker and marketer licensing.
  5. Public Utility Commission of Texas, Broker registration and reporting, broker registration requirement.
  6. Ohio Administrative Code, Chapter 4901:1-24, certification of power brokers and aggregators.

Find out what your bills should have cost.

Send one recent bill per site, or a list of accounts. We tell you where we expect findings before you sign anything. No upfront audit fee.