Request a bill review
Discovery Energy · Services

A second opinion on bills someone already "audits"

Having an energy manager is not the same as having every account tested against its tariff. Our independent, contingency-based review runs behind your existing providers, without replacing them, and costs nothing unless it finds money.

A second-opinion utility audit is an independent, account-by-account review of electricity and natural gas bills that another provider already manages, pays or "audits". It tests each account against the utility's own tariff and classification rules, which supply-focused and payment-focused services are usually not scoped to do.

01 / 06

Why errors survive behind an existing provider

Most multi-site companies already pay someone to look after utility costs: an energy manager, a broker, a bill-pay vendor, a software platform or an internal AP team. Few of them are hired to answer one narrow question for every account: is the utility billing it under the right rate, rider, meter setup and classification, as its tariff defines them?

The costliest errors often do not look wrong on the invoice. An account on the wrong rate class is billed correctly for the class it was given, so the math checks out and the error repeats until someone tests the class itself against the utility's criteria.

Existing providerWhat it is usually hired to doWhat can be left untested
Energy broker or procurement consultantBuy electricity and gas supply at a competitive priceDelivery charges, rate class and riders set by the utility; sites in states where it is not licensed or where there is no supplier choice
Energy managerProcurement, usage tracking, budgets, sometimes auditingAccount-by-account checks of utility-assigned classification, as the steel case below shows
Previous utility auditorRecover past overchargesAccounts outside a sample, smaller sites, error types it did not test, changes since the audit
Bill-pay vendorReceive, pay and code bills on timeWhether the rate behind a correctly paid bill is the right one
Software platformCapture bill data, flag spikes and anomaliesTariff errors inside correctly captured data, where nothing changes month to month
Internal AP or controller reviewConfirm the bill was approved and paid for the invoiced amountWhether the utility calculated that amount under the correct tariff, season, meter and classification

Coverage gaps are often structural

Procurement coverage is limited by law and by market design. Some states license or register energy brokers: Pennsylvania licenses broker/marketers as electric generation suppliers, and New York's Public Service Law §66-t requires energy brokers and energy consultants to register with the state's Public Service Commission. Supplier choice is also limited: the US Energy Information Administration (EIA) reported in 2019 that 19 states and the District of Columbia allowed some commercial and industrial customers to choose a competitive supplier, and retail choice is generally available only to customers of investor-owned utilities. Where there is no supplier choice, there is no contract for a broker to place, so those accounts may never get a specialist review.

Audits have limits too. One that samples the largest accounts skips the regular-sized ones that make up most of a portfolio, and any audit is a snapshot taken before the next expansion, shift change or acquisition.

02 / 06

Who a second opinion is for

A second-opinion audit is most useful for multi-site commercial and industrial organizations, from about 10 to more than 1,000 utility accounts, where one or more of these is true:

  • An energy manager or broker says auditing is "included", but no one has seen account-level findings with tariff citations.
  • Sites span several states or provinces, and some are in regulated territories or in states the broker does not cover.
  • A previous audit reviewed only large accounts, or only one fuel.
  • The company has made acquisitions, and acquired sites kept the rate classes, riders and meters they had under prior ownership.
  • Plants have changed load: new equipment, new shifts, idled buildings, meter replacements.
  • An internal review has already been done and found nothing conclusive, yet leadership still suspects errors.

A second opinion does not mean the incumbent has failed. The scopes are often different.

03 / 06

What we have found behind incumbents

National steel company with an active energy-management contract

A publicly traded national steel company already had an energy management provider under contract for procurement and auditing services. After reviewing a sample of its bills, Discovery proposed an independent, contingency-based audit behind that relationship, rather than in place of it. Testing each account's assigned rate class against each utility's own criteria found 17 misclassified accounts at facilities in Indiana, Massachusetts, Nebraska, Minnesota, Colorado, Texas and Missouri.

One-time refunds$374,326Across 17 misclassified accounts in 7 states.
Recurring savings$150,000+A year, identified across the portfolio.
One gas account$33,554A year: San Antonio, Texas, billed on Schedule G, qualified for Schedule LVG.

No change to plant operations was required. Read the national steel company case study.

103-facility company with an auditor, a broker and a bill-pay vendor

A specialty industrial services provider with 103 facilities had already hired an audit firm, a procurement broker licensed in two states and a stand-alone bill-pay vendor. More than half of its locations still paid late fees every month after an acquisition. Once every account was consolidated into one inventory and audited, sites that had already been through the earlier audit produced further recoveries, facilities outside the broker's two states were evaluated for supply for the first time, and late fees were eliminated. Read the 103-facility case study.

04 / 06

What the second-opinion audit includes

  • Every account in scope, not a sample. Accounts receive roughly the same scrutiny unless you ask for a different approach or utility rules limit the review.
  • Electricity and natural gas. Water, sewer and other utilities are not audited; they can be included in bill pay.
  • Tariff-level checks. Rate class, tariff dates and seasons, meter readings and multipliers, demand and ratchets, riders and optional programs, corporate classification, estimated reads and true-ups, and, in PJM and ERCOT, capacity and transmission tags.
  • Software plus specialists. TaraBase verifies calculations and flags anomalies; specialists read the tariff, validate each finding and document it for the utility.
  • Regulated and deregulated markets across the US and Canada, so the review covers the whole footprint, not only the states where supply can be bought.
  • Audit-only scope. No procurement is required, and the review does not depend on which supplier you use.

How it works

  1. Share bills or an account list

    Send one recent bill per site, or a list of accounts with service addresses. We tell you where we expect findings before you sign anything.

  2. Authorize

    Sign a letter of authorization (LOA) so we can request billing history and interval data directly from each utility. No hardware, no site visit.

  3. Test every account

    We review 36 to 48 months of bills against the tariffs in force at the time, including accounts your incumbent has already reviewed.

  4. Findings meeting

    First findings usually arrive in 30 to 60 days, presented in a meeting with the tariff sheet or rule behind each one.

  5. Approve and file

    You approve each claim. We file it and handle every utility conversation. Refunds usually take a further 60 to 120 days.

  6. Confirm the correction

    We confirm each refund or credit as it posts and check later bills to show the correction held.

Working alongside your incumbent

Agree at the start how the audit will coordinate with current providers and how any overlapping findings will be handled. Before you begin, check your existing agreements for who holds rights to findings on which accounts, and which accounts a previous auditor already claimed. Nothing changes on any account, tariff, supplier or payment without your written approval, so the incumbent's work is not disturbed.

05 / 06

What you receive

  • A findings report, presented in a meeting, separating one-time refunds, recurring savings and items needing more data.
  • For each claim, the tariff sheet or rule it relies on and the calculation of what should have been billed.
  • Copies of what is filed with the utility, and the utility's response.
  • Proof of each refund or credit as it posts, and confirmation on later bills that the correction held.
  • Savings measured against a baseline agreed in writing before work starts.

If every account is already correct, you receive documentation that it is, at no cost. That gives management a documented basis for relying on the incumbent's work.

How it is priced

There is no upfront fee, retainer or setup charge. The fee is usually 15% to 50% of qualifying refunds, credits and verified savings, paid only after you receive them; the rate depends on the size of the accounts and whether Discovery manages other parts of your energy program. The fee typically applies to refunds plus the first year of savings, or the period your agreement sets. Utilities never pay us. If you want proof first, start with a 15-account pilot audit on representative accounts, including your hardest tariffs, or a free rate class check. See pricing and how we stay independent.

How it fits with other services

Many clients keep their incumbent for procurement and use Discovery for tariff-level validation. Others later add energy procurement with any supplier commission disclosed before a contract is signed, bill pay with review before payment, TaraBase reporting or full multi-site energy management on the same account inventory.

06 / 06

Questions buyers ask

Will this conflict with our current provider?

No. The audit is a records review that runs alongside existing contracts. Many clients keep their incumbent for procurement and use Discovery for tariff-level validation. Check your current agreements for rights to findings on specific accounts, and agree up front how overlaps are handled.

Why would an incumbent miss errors?

Large energy managers and brokers are built around supply purchasing. Account-by-account tariff testing is slow, specialist work, and accounts outside their focus, smaller sites or states they are not licensed in, are often never reviewed. A wrong rate class also produces a bill whose math is correct, so it does not show up as an anomaly.

Our energy manager says they already audit our bills. Is a second opinion still worth it?

That was the situation at a national steel company. Auditing was in scope with its incumbent provider; an independent review still found 17 misclassified accounts, $374,326 in refunds and more than $150,000 a year in recurring savings.

What if you find nothing?

You owe nothing and receive documentation that your accounts were billed correctly.

Sources

  1. Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission, Electric Generation Supplier application resources, broker/marketers are licensed as electric generation suppliers and do not take title to electricity.
  2. New York State Department of Public Service, Energy Broker and Energy Consultant Registration, Public Service Law §66-t requires energy brokers and consultants to register; rules require disclosure of broker compensation.
  3. US EIA, Today in Energy, November 1, 2019, 19 states and the District of Columbia allow some commercial and industrial customers to choose competitive retail power marketers.
  4. US EIA, FAQ: Can electric utility customers choose their electricity supplier?, retail choice is generally available only to customers of investor-owned utilities.

Find out what your bills should have cost.

Send one recent bill per site, or a list of accounts. We tell you where we expect findings before you sign anything. No upfront audit fee.