Request a bill review
Discovery Energy · Provider types

Types of utility cost providers, and which you need

"Utility cost management" covers several different jobs. Knowing which job a provider actually does, and how it is paid, is the fastest way to build a shortlist and to see where money can fall between vendors.

Utility cost providers fall into a few groups: utility bill auditors that recover past overcharges and correct rates, energy brokers and procurement consultants that buy supply, bill-pay providers that receive and pay bills, software platforms that capture and analyze bill data, energy managers that run part or all of a program, demand-response providers, and integrated firms that combine several of these on one account inventory.

01 / 06

The provider types side by side

Categories overlap, and many firms sell more than one service. Read the table as a list of jobs, then ask each provider which ones it will do for you.

Provider typeMain jobUsually paid byLooks atDoes not usually
Utility bill auditorRecover past overcharges, move accounts to the correct rateClient, contingency share of refunds and savingsPast bills against tariffs, rate classes, meters, ridersPay bills or buy energy
Multi-category expense auditorAudit utilities plus waste, telecom and other overheadClient, shared savingsInvoices across many spend categoriesSpecialize in energy tariffs only
Energy broker or procurement consultantBuy electricity and gas supply; manage price riskSupplier commission in the price, or a client feeSupply offers, contract terms, market timingTest delivery charges against tariffs
Bill-pay providerReceive, pay and code bills on timeClient, per bill or per accountDue dates, payment status, GL codingFile retroactive tariff claims
Utility data software platformCapture, store and analyze bill data; flag anomaliesClient, subscriptionTrends, spikes, benchmarks, budgetsDecide whether a site still qualifies for its rate
Energy managerRun some or all of the program: procurement, reporting, sometimes auditingClient fee, supplier commission or bothSupply, usage and reportingTest every account's utility-assigned classification
Demand-response providerEarn from and cut peak loadRevenue shareInterval load and grid eventsAudit bills
Integrated providerAudit, procurement, bill pay and reporting on one inventoryPer service, disclosedAll of the above for each accountDevelop energy projects

Descriptions are general. Scope varies by firm, so confirm current services and compensation with each provider in writing.

02 / 06

When each type fits

Utility bill auditor

Fits when you suspect past overcharges, have never had a specialist review, or have changed sites through expansion or acquisition. A good auditor tests each account against the utility's published tariff and classification rules, not just the bill's arithmetic, and documents each claim for the utility. Auditors differ in which utilities they cover, whether they review every account or a sample, and how far back they pursue refunds. Most work on contingency.

Energy broker or procurement consultant

Fits when supply contracts are expiring in markets where you can choose a supplier. That choice is limited: the US Energy Information Administration (EIA) reported in 2019 that 19 states and the District of Columbia allowed some commercial and industrial customers to choose a competitive supplier, and retail choice is generally available only to customers of investor-owned utilities. Brokers are also licensed or registered state by state. Pennsylvania licenses broker/marketers as electric generation suppliers, and New York requires energy brokers and consultants to register and disclose broker compensation. A broker's reach is therefore only as wide as its licenses and the choice markets in your footprint. Brokers are usually paid a commission built into the supplier's price; consultants are usually paid a fee by the client.

Bill-pay provider

Fits when bills are late, data is scattered and AP spends too much time on utility invoices. Bill pay receives every bill, pays it on time and codes it to the general ledger. Ask who holds the funds: some providers ask you to prefund an account they control; others pay from an account you control. Bill pay pays what is billed. Unless the provider also tests rates against tariffs, a bill on the wrong rate is paid on time, every month.

Utility data software platform

Fits when you want your own team to track usage, cost and emissions. The US Department of Energy describes these tools, energy management information systems, as covering utility bill management, including bill validation that checks for errors such as incorrect meter readings or charges, payment processing, budgeting and cost allocation. Software handles volume well but is less suited to account-specific questions, such as whether a site still qualifies for its rate class.

Energy manager

Fits a company that wants to outsource most of its energy program. Many energy managers are built around procurement and reporting, and "auditing" in their contracts can mean anomaly checks rather than account-by-account tariff testing. Ask exactly which checks are performed on which accounts.

Demand-response provider

Fits sites with flexible load that can be curtailed during grid events, especially where capacity costs are rising. A capacity tag check is a sensible first step before deciding how much load to commit.

Integrated provider

Fits multi-site companies that want audit, procurement, bill pay and reporting on one account inventory, so a finding in one function reaches the others. Each fee should still be shown separately.

03 / 06

Choosing by problem

  • "We think we were overcharged." A utility bill auditor or an integrated provider.
  • "Bills are late and data is a mess." Bill pay with review before payment.
  • "Contracts are expiring." Procurement, after an audit sets a clean baseline.
  • "PJM capacity costs jumped." A capacity-tag check, then peak reduction or demand response.
  • "We have hundreds of sites and no single view." An integrated provider, or clearly divided roles.
  • "We already have an energy manager." An independent second-opinion audit behind it.
  • "We just closed an acquisition." An audit of the acquired accounts before their rates become the new baseline.

Where the gaps appear

Each provider type is good at its own job. Money leaks between them:

  • A bill-pay provider pays a bill on the wrong rate, on time.
  • A broker never covers the states it is not licensed in, or regulated territories with no supplier choice.
  • A software platform captures every line correctly, including a wrong rate class.
  • An auditor that samples large accounts never sees the smaller ones, or the late fees.

At one 103-facility company with an auditor, a two-state broker and a bill-pay vendor, more than half the sites still paid late fees monthly. How an integrated approach closes those gaps.

04 / 06

Questions to ask any provider

Which jobs will you do for us, exactly?

Audit, procurement, payment, reporting, demand response. Get the scope in writing, including utility types excluded.

Every account, or a sample?

Ask which checks run on every account: rate class, tariff dates, meter multipliers, demand and ratchets, riders, corporate classification.

How are you paid, by whom?

List every compensation source, including supplier commissions, and whether the audit can be bought without procurement.

Where can you work?

Which states and provinces you are licensed or able to serve, including regulated territories, compared with your site list.

Who controls the money?

For bill pay: who holds funds, who approves payments, and how payments are reconciled.

What can you change without us?

The right answer is nothing that changes an account, tariff, supplier or payment detail without written approval.

Common mistakes

  • Treating "audit included" as a full audit. Ask for account-level findings with tariff citations from the last review.
  • Buying supply before checking delivery charges. Errors in rate class or multipliers become part of the baseline used to judge supply bids.
  • Assuming bill pay prevents overcharges. Paying on time and paying the right amount are different tests.
  • Letting coverage follow the vendor's licenses. Match each provider's footprint to your site list, state by state.

05 / 06

How Discovery fits

Discovery is an integrated provider for multi-site commercial and industrial organizations: tariff-level audits plus procurement, bill pay and TaraBase reporting for electricity and natural gas, on one account inventory, across regulated and deregulated markets in the US and Canada. Each service can also be engaged alone, including an audit behind your current broker or energy manager.

Audits
Electricity and natural gas only, every account in scope. Contingency, usually 15% to 50% of refunds and verified savings, no upfront fee.
Procurement
Fixed monthly fee, or a supplier commission disclosed before any contract is signed.
Bill pay
Electricity, gas, water, sewer and any other utility type, paid from a funding account you control and coded to your GL.
Not offered
Audits of telecom, water rates, street lights or franchise fees, and energy project development.

Organizations whose largest exposure is in telecom, water or other non-energy categories are better served by a firm that audits those. See how we are paid and stay independent.

06 / 06

Questions buyers ask

Is one provider enough for a multi-site company?

It can be, if the provider genuinely covers audit, payment and procurement across your whole footprint. Otherwise, assign each function explicitly and make sure someone owns the gaps between them.

What is the difference between an energy broker and a utility bill auditor?

A broker looks forward and buys future supply, usually for a commission built into the supplier's price. An auditor looks back and checks whether the utility billed each account correctly under its tariff, usually for a share of refunds and savings. See audit vs procurement.

Does a bill-pay provider audit our bills?

Most check for spikes, duplicates and late fees before payment. Fewer test whether each account is on the correct rate class, rider and classification, or file retroactive claims. Ask which checks run before payment and who pursues refunds.

Where does Discovery Energy fit?

Discovery is an integrated provider: tariff-level audits plus procurement, bill pay and TaraBase reporting for electricity and natural gas, on one account inventory. Each service can also be engaged alone.

Sources

  1. US EIA, Today in Energy, November 1, 2019, 19 states and the District of Columbia allow some commercial and industrial customers to choose competitive retail power marketers.
  2. US EIA, FAQ: Can electric utility customers choose their electricity supplier?, retail choice is generally available only to customers of investor-owned utilities.
  3. Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission, Electric Generation Supplier application resources, broker/marketers are licensed as electric generation suppliers.
  4. New York State Department of Public Service, Energy Broker and Energy Consultant Registration, registration under Public Service Law §66-t and disclosure of broker compensation.
  5. US Department of Energy, FEMP, Energy management information system capabilities, utility bill management including bill validation, payment processing, budgeting and cost allocation.

Find out what your bills should have cost.

Send one recent bill per site, or a list of accounts. We tell you where we expect findings before you sign anything. No upfront audit fee.