Meter multiplier errors
A meter multiplier error occurs when the factor a utility uses to convert a meter's reading into billed usage does not match the meter actually installed. Every bill is then wrong by the same proportion, silently, until someone checks the multiplier against the meter configuration.
This page explains how multipliers work on large electric and gas services, how they go wrong, what regulators have done when they did, and how to check the multiplier on your own bills.
01 / 07
How a meter multiplier works
On a large commercial or industrial service, the current and voltage are too high to run straight through a meter. Instead, current transformers (CTs) and potential transformers (PTs, also called voltage transformers) step them down in a fixed ratio, and the meter records a small, proportional share of the real load. The billing system multiplies the meter's reading back up.
New Brunswick Power explains it with a worked example. A PT with a 360:120 ratio gives a multiplier of 3. A CT with a 400:5 ratio gives 80. Together they form a circuit multiplier of 240. The meter itself has an internal multiplier, in this case 2, shown on its face. The billing multiplier is the product, 480, and it is the number printed on the invoice. Usage equals the difference between the present and previous readings times that multiplier, and the same factor applies to demand.
Gas meters have their own conversion factors. Where gas is delivered above standard pressure, the utility applies a pressure factor; CPS Energy's general-service gas tariff, for example, adjusts measurements taken above four ounces of pressure to the equivalent of four ounces. Bills then convert volume to therms or dekatherms with a heat content factor. Large gas meters may also have electronic volume correctors that apply these factors before the reading reaches the bill.
Why it compounds
The bill still adds up. Usage looks plausible because it is a fixed multiple of the truth. If the multiplier has been wrong since the meter was installed, there is no earlier, correct bill to compare against. Neither accounts payable nor the utility's system flags it, so it can persist for years.
02 / 07
How multiplier errors happen
- A meter exchange. The replacement meter has a different internal multiplier, or the field paperwork is right but the billing system keeps the old factor, or receives the wrong new one.
- A CT or PT change. Transformers are replaced or resized during a service upgrade or equipment project, and the new ratio never reaches billing.
- Dual-ratio transformers. Some CTs have two windings with different ratios. The meter is wired to one and billed as if it were wired to the other.
- A multiplier never entered. A new account is set up with a multiplier of 1, so usage is billed at a fraction of the real figure. This one favors the customer until the utility finds it.
- Double counting. A meter programmed to record primary values is still billed with a transformer multiplier, multiplying usage twice.
- Gas factor errors. A wrong or missing pressure factor on an elevated-pressure service, or a wrong correction factor after a meter or corrector exchange.
Illustrative example, not a client result
A plant's service uses 400:5 CTs, a factor of 80. During a meter exchange, the billing system is set up with the factor for 600:5 CTs, which is 120. Every reading is now billed 50% high. A site that really uses 200,000 kWh a month is billed for 300,000, and its billed demand is 50% high as well. At an average of 8 cents per kWh for energy alone, the overcharge is $8,000 a month before demand charges, and the bill looks entirely normal.
03 / 07
What regulators have decided
Multiplier errors reach state commissions in both directions, and the cases show how much the start date of the error matters.
- Michigan, 2015
- Three revenue meters serving an integrated steel mill in Dearborn were installed on January 31, 2008 with a billing multiplier of 48,000, equal to a 2000:5 CT ratio. The CT windings feeding them were 1500:5, a multiplier of 36,000. The customer found the mismatch in 2014 after a very high demand reading led it to compare the utility's meters with its own. The utility agreed to refund only two months. The Michigan Public Service Commission found the error ran from February 2008 through March 2014 and ordered a refund of $19.651 million plus 7% annual interest (Case U-17663).
- New York, 2022
- After a 2013 meter exchange at a large commercial customer in Brooklyn, the utility's system recorded a multiplier of 160 instead of 800, underbilling the account for almost six years. When the utility corrected it in 2019, it limited a $658,213 backbill to 12 months under state rules. A 2022 informal hearing decision, after reviewing when the utility should have become aware of the error, cancelled a further $73,463 of backbilled charges plus late payment charges (Case 021386).
- Idaho, 2000
- A utility found an incorrect multiplier on a residential account that had been used since the meter was installed in 1991. It back-billed the maximum three years allowed by Idaho law, and the Commission upheld the back-billing (Order No. 28298).
State rules name the error directly. South Dakota's billing rule covers overcharges and undercharges caused by an incorrect multiplier or constant, refunds overcharges from the date of the error, and limits the period to 12 months when that date cannot be determined. Idaho's rules require a corrected billing when metering equipment was incorrectly installed or programmed, reaching back up to three years if the start can be dated.
04 / 07
Who is most exposed
- Large electric services metered through CTs and PTs, including primary-metered plants. These are the accounts with the largest bills, so a small ratio error is a large dollar error.
- Sites that had a service upgrade, a new transformer or a meter exchange in the past few years, including utility-wide smart meter replacement programs.
- Plants with several meters and substations, such as steel and metals plants and large manufacturing campuses, where one meter can be wrong while the others are right.
- Gas customers on elevated-pressure or large-volume services, including food processors, RNG producers and paper and packaging mills, where pressure and correction factors apply.
05 / 07
How to check for it yourself
Record the multiplier on every bill
Note the meter number and multiplier printed on each bill for at least 36 months. Any change should line up with a known meter or transformer change.
Compare with the installed equipment
Ask your electrician or the utility for the CT and PT ratios and the meter's internal multiplier. Multiply them and compare the result with the billing multiplier.
Look for step changes
Check usage and demand in the months after any meter exchange or service work. A sudden jump or drop with no operational cause is the classic sign.
Compare with your own data
Billed kWh and kW should track interval data, submeters or a building management system. A constant ratio between them points to the multiplier.
Test the size of the numbers
Compare billed demand with the rating of the service and the connected equipment. Demand above what the service can physically carry is impossible.
Check gas factors
Confirm the pressure factor matches the delivery pressure in your service agreement, and that the heat content factor follows the utility's published values.
06 / 07
How it is corrected, and what can be recovered
A multiplier claim usually starts with a request that the utility verify the metering installation in the field: transformer ratios, wiring and the meter's programming. Once the correct factor is confirmed, the utility rebills the affected period.
Over-billing is generally refundable for the period the state and utility allow, which is typically 1 to 5 years, set by each state and utility. Some rules extend further when the customer can document when the error began, as the Michigan case shows: the date of the meter installation, exchange or service upgrade is the most valuable piece of evidence in the file. See how far back utilities refund overcharges, by state.
Under-billing can also be back-billed by the utility, which is one more reason to check before the utility does. Back-billing limits are often shorter than refund periods, but they still apply: in the New York case, the utility collected 12 months.
07 / 07
Questions buyers ask
What is a meter multiplier?
A factor that converts what a meter records into the usage quantity used for billing. Large commercial and industrial meters often record a fraction of actual flow through current or potential transformers, so the reading must be multiplied.
When do multiplier errors usually start?
Most often after a meter exchange or transformer change, when the billing system keeps the old multiplier or receives the wrong new one. They can also start when a new account is set up.
Where do I find the multiplier?
The billing multiplier is usually printed on the bill next to the meter readings, sometimes labelled constant or factor. The meter's internal multiplier is on its face. Transformer ratios are on the transformers' nameplates or in the utility's metering records.
Does a multiplier error affect demand charges too?
Yes. The same factor scales kW, so demand charges, ratchets and any energy blocks tied to demand are all off by the same proportion. See demand charge errors.
Could checking the multiplier lead to a back-bill?
It can, if the multiplier was too low. Utilities can back-bill under-billing within the limits their state allows. Knowing early lets you plan for it rather than receive it unexpectedly.
Do you need to visit the site to check it?
No. Discovery reviews bills, meter data and tariffs off-site under a letter of authorization. Where the numbers point to a multiplier problem, the utility verifies the installation in the field.
Sources
- NB Power, How to understand the multiplier, CT, PT, circuit, meter and billing multipliers and the worked example.
- CPS Energy, General Service Gas Rate G, adjustment of gas metered above four ounces of pressure.
- Michigan Public Service Commission, Order in Case U-17663 (July 9, 2015), 48,000 versus 36,000 multiplier, error period, Rule 17 refund limit and the $19.651 million refund with 7% interest.
- New York Department of Public Service, Informal Hearing Decision, Case 021386 (January 31, 2022), 160 versus 800 multiplier, 12-month backbill limit and the cancelled $73,463.
- Idaho Public Utilities Commission, Order No. 28298 (2000), incorrect multiplier since 1991 and three-year back-billing upheld.
- South Dakota Administrative Rules, ARSD 20:10:17:09, incorrect multiplier or constant as a billing error, refund from the date of error, 12 months if undetermined.
- Idaho Public Utilities Commission, IDAPA 31.21.01, Rule 203, corrected billing for incorrectly installed or programmed metering equipment and the three-year limit.
Find out what your bills should have cost.
Send one recent bill per site, or a list of accounts. We tell you where we expect findings before you sign anything. No upfront audit fee.