Request a bill review
Discovery Energy ยท Billing Error Library

Demand charge and ratchet errors

A demand charge error is an incorrect billed peak demand, in kW, caused by a misread or stuck meter, a wrong multiplier, a misapplied tariff or a miscalculated ratchet. Because demand can be a large share of a commercial electric bill, small errors compound quickly.

How demand and ratchets are billed, how they go wrong, how to check your own accounts and how demand errors are corrected and refunded.

01 / 07

How demand is billed

Most commercial and industrial electric bills charge for two things: energy, in kWh, and demand, in kW. Demand is the highest average rate of use in a short interval during the billing period, usually 15, 30 or 60 minutes depending on the tariff. One interval sets the charge for the whole month, so a site that runs at 400 kW for 29 days and touches 700 kW for half an hour is billed for 700 kW.

Demand charges are widespread and can be expensive. A 2017 survey of US tariffs by the National Renewable Energy Laboratory estimated that nearly 5 million commercial customers, over a quarter of the 18 million in the US, can subscribe to tariffs with demand charges above $15 per kW.

Many tariffs then turn measured demand into billing demand with further rules:

  • Ratchets. A ratchet is a minimum demand charge set by a past peak. A typical ratchet, as the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory describes it, uses 80% of the highest peak in the previous 11 months, so a 1,000 kW peak sets an 800 kW floor for nearly a year.
  • Seasonal ratchets. Georgia Power's Power and Light Large schedule (PLL-18) measures demand over 30 minutes and sets billing demand at the greatest of the current month's demand, 95% of the highest previous summer month (June through September) or 60% of the highest winter month, within the current and preceding 11 months.
  • Contract and minimum demand. The same schedule never bills less than the contract minimum, 50% of total contract capacity or 500 kW, whichever is greatest.
  • Power factor. Some tariffs bill reactive demand (kVAR) when power factor is low. PLL-18 bills excess kVAR above one-third of measured kW at $0.42 per excess kVAR where power factor is below 95% lagging.
  • Time-of-use demand. Some schedules bill only on-peak demand, or price on-peak and off-peak demand separately.

02 / 07

How demand errors happen

CauseWhat goes wrongSign on the bill
Stuck or failed demand registerThe meter or its communication stops updating and the last value repeats.The same kW month after month. Real demand moves.
Wrong meter multiplierLarge services read through current and potential transformers. A wrong factor scales every kW reading. See meter multiplier errors.A step change in kW and kWh together, often after a meter exchange.
Ratchet set from the wrong monthThe floor is taken from a peak outside the tariff's look-back window or season, or from an estimated read.Billed demand above metered demand, with a floor that does not match any peak in the window.
Wrong ratchet percentageThe system applies a percentage from another schedule or an older version of the tariff.Billed demand is a different share of the peak than the tariff states.
Ratchet kept after the windowThe floor keeps billing after the look-back period ends, or after a change of schedule that should have reset it.A floor still applied 12 or more months after the peak that set it.
Demand above the schedule's limitsBilled demand exceeds the maximum the rate schedule allows, which means either the reading or the schedule is wrong.kW above the schedule's stated range.
Misapplied power factor or kVAR chargeThe adjustment is based on a faulty reading, or continues after capacitors were installed.A power factor line that never changes, or appears with no kVAR reading.

Some ratchet costs are not errors. If the tariff has a ratchet and the utility applied it correctly to a real peak, the charge stands, even if the peak came from a start-up test or a one-day event. The audit question is whether the percentage, window, season and starting peak on the bill match the tariff. Separately, some tariffs allow relief when load is permanently reduced; see site closures, idling and acquisitions.

Illustrative example, not a client result

With an 80% ratchet, a one-time 600 kW peak sets a 480 kW billing floor. At $15 per kW, a site that returns to 450 kW still pays for 480, an extra $450 a month. If the billing system had instead applied a 90% ratchet from an older tariff, the floor would be 540 kW, and the site would pay for 90 kW it does not owe under the current tariff: $1,350 a month, or $16,200 over a 12-month window.

03 / 07

Who is most exposed

  • Sites with large motors and process loads. Compressors, mills, extruders, furnaces and chillers at manufacturing plants, steel and metals and plastics plants create sharp peaks, especially at start-up.
  • Seasonal operations. Grain dryers at agribusiness sites and summer refrigeration loads at cold storage and food processing plants set peaks that ratchets carry into the off-season.
  • Sites that changed load. A line removed, a building idled or a shift dropped leaves a ratchet billing against equipment that is gone.
  • Sites after a meter exchange or service upgrade. New meters, transformers and multipliers are a common start date for demand errors.

In competitive markets, a related charge is set by load in a few system peak hours rather than by the site's own monthly peak. See capacity tag errors and ERCOT 4CP transmission charges.

04 / 07

How to check for it yourself

Gather 24 months of bills, the current rate schedule and, if you can get it, the utility's interval data for the account.

Chart billed against metered demand

Put metered kW and billed kW side by side for every month. Where they differ, the tariff must explain the gap.

Look for repeated values

The same demand figure for three or more months, to the decimal, points to a stuck register or an estimate.

Rebuild the ratchet

From the tariff, note the percentage, the look-back window and any seasonal rule. Recalculate each month's floor and compare it with the bill.

Check the schedule's limits

Confirm billed demand sits inside the range the schedule allows, and that contract or minimum demand matches your service agreement.

Compare with interval data

The highest interval in the utility's own data should equal billed maximum demand, using the tariff's interval length.

Check after every meter change

Compare kW and kWh before and after any meter, transformer or multiplier change, and confirm the multiplier on the bill.

Review power factor lines

Confirm kVAR readings exist, the threshold matches the tariff, and charges stopped if you corrected power factor.

05 / 07

How demand errors are corrected and refunded

A demand claim needs evidence that the billed figure was wrong: interval data, a meter test, a pattern of repeated values, or a calculation showing the tariff's ratchet produces a different number. The utility investigates, often by testing or replacing the meter and reviewing its own data, and then rebills the affected months.

How far back the correction reaches depends on the state rule and whether the start of the error can be dated. Rules for meter errors and billing errors are not always the same, and some states count back from the date the error was found while others count from the date the claim is filed. See how far back utilities refund overcharges, by state. Because demand errors repeat every month and ratchets carry them forward, the corrected bills going forward are often worth as much as the refund.

06 / 07

A real example

At an agribusiness facility in Clayton, North Carolina, billed demand stuck at 1,000 kW for seven consecutive months, then stuck at a second value, 1,673 kW, for at least nine more months. Both values were well above the facility's actual metered demand, and in the second period above the maximum demand allowed under its rate schedule. Discovery noticed the pattern and investigated it directly with Duke Energy, which confirmed the billing demand reading was erroneous and refunded $97,843.

Demand-billing refund$97,843Clayton, North Carolina, confirmed by Duke Energy.
Total one-time refunds, same facility$117,412Including a separate $19,569 rate-schedule correction.

The lesson is simple: a demand reading that stays exactly the same for months is not a sign of stability. It is a sign that something has stopped updating. Read the diversified agribusiness case.

07 / 07

Questions buyers ask

What causes incorrect demand charges?

Meter misreads, incorrect meter multipliers, a misapplied tariff, or a billing system that calculates peak demand or the ratchet incorrectly. Peak demand is commonly measured over a short interval, often 15 minutes, though some tariffs use 30 or 60.

What is a demand ratchet?

A tariff rule that sets a minimum billed demand based on a past peak, for example 80% of the highest demand in the previous 11 months. A single spike can raise bills for most of a year.

Can we get a refund for a ratchet set by a one-time spike?

Usually not, if the spike was real and the utility applied the ratchet as the tariff states. A refund is available when the ratchet was calculated wrongly: the wrong percentage, month, season or window, or a peak that was never actually recorded.

What data do we need to check demand charges?

Bills for at least 24 months, the rate schedule, and the utility's interval data for the account. Utilities can usually provide interval data to the customer or to an auditor under a letter of authorization.

Does a demand error affect more than the demand line?

Often. Some tariffs price energy in blocks tied to billing demand, and ratchets carry a wrong peak into later months. A multiplier error also scales kWh, so both lines are wrong.

How does Discovery check demand?

Off-site, from bills, meter data and tariffs obtained under a letter of authorization, with no hardware and no site visit. Each month's billed demand is rebuilt from the tariff and compared with the meter data.

Sources

  1. National Renewable Energy Laboratory (via OSTI), Identifying Potential Markets for Behind-the-Meter Battery Energy Storage: A Survey of U.S. Demand Charges (2017), nearly 5 million of 18 million US commercial customers can subscribe to tariffs with demand charges above $15 per kW.
  2. Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, FEDS: What is a demand ratchet?, typical ratchet of 80% of the previous 11 months' peak and the 1,000 kW to 800 kW example.
  3. Georgia Power, Power and Light Large Schedule PLL-18, 30-minute demand, 95% summer and 60% winter ratchets, minimum billing demand, energy blocks priced by hours times billing demand, and the excess kVAR charge.

Find out what your bills should have cost.

Send one recent bill per site, or a list of accounts. We tell you where we expect findings before you sign anything. No upfront audit fee.