New York natural gas case study, Buffalo, New York. November 2026
Buffalo-area natural gas capacity: ample supply reported, whole-system margin below 5%
In May 2026 National Fuel told New York regulators ample firm capacity is available. Its tables put whole-system FY 2027 capacity at 1,019,457 dekatherms (Dth) per day against design day demand of 989,203, a 3.06% margin, below the 5% threshold.
Metro used: the Buffalo-Cheektowaga, NY metropolitan statistical area, as delineated in OMB Bulletin No. 23-01 (July 21, 2023): Erie and Niagara counties. The gas utility identified in the record is National Fuel Gas Distribution Corporation (National Fuel). Every capacity figure below is for National Fuel's whole system, not the two counties alone.5
Key takeaways
- National Fuel's May 2026 report says it has no significant areas of concern or vulnerability due to supply or delivery constraints, and that ample firm capacity is available.3
- By our subtraction the margin is similar in FY 2028 and FY 2029, and each year is below the Outlook Scale's 5% thin-margin threshold.2
- National Fuel said it does not anticipate needing to propose a moratorium on new connections during the plan period.3
- The consultant to Staff said in 2023 that hydraulic modeling revealed pressures below minimum design pressures in isolated pockets of the low-pressure system; the passage does not locate them.4
- The Commission's December 2023 order records the consultant's finding that National Fuel's 74 heating degree day design day was a reasonable assumption.4
- National Fuel named three future risks: declining local production, transportation customers converting to sales service, and loss of energy service company (ESCO) capacity, a potential system-wide risk.3
What is the outlook for Buffalo gas capacity through 2029?
Discovery Energy rates the outlook for Buffalo-area natural gas capacity through 2029 as Elevated (confidence: Medium): National Fuel's own tables put total capacity only about 3.1% above design day demand in each year, a thin margin.2 The record we reviewed shows no scheduled capacity addition.1 National Fuel says ample firm capacity is available and reports no vulnerable locations; every figure is for its whole system, not the two counties alone.3 Documented risk factors: none found in the record we reviewed beyond the thin margin itself. Three developments would change the assessment: National Fuel's next annual report, around May 2027, with updated capacity and design day demand tables; any change to the ESCO capacity, large industrial supplies or local production assumptions behind the capacity table; a hydraulic modeling update that locates the low-pressure pockets the consultant found.
Outlook levels, from least to most concern: Stable, Watch, Elevated, High, Severe. Levels describe the public record of capacity and supply risk; confidence is reported separately. They are qualitative assessments, not forecasts of outages.
Who serves the Buffalo area?
National Fuel's plan appendices say its New York territory extends from the Pennsylvania border with Cattaraugus and Allegany counties north to Niagara County. A 2021 market study in those appendices lists Buffalo, Amherst, Cheektowaga and other Erie County communities and Niagara Falls, North Tonawanda and other Niagara County communities among those served, so the utility is identified for both metro counties. How much of each county National Fuel serves is not shown, and whether any other gas utility serves part of the two counties is not shown.5
| Where | Item in the record |
|---|---|
| Inside the metro | Erie County and Niagara County communities named in National Fuel's plan |
| Outside the metro | National Fuel's other counties (Allegany, Cattaraugus, Chautauqua and others) |
| Unclear | Any other gas utility in Erie or Niagara County |
National Fuel's service territory by whether it falls inside the Buffalo metro (OMB delineation). Sources: Final Long-Term Plan Appendices D to K, Appendix H.5
The record does not allocate any of these whole-system figures to the two counties.
How much spare gas capacity does Buffalo have on the coldest day?
In words: what the map shows
- Pipelines labeled: National Fuel Gas Supply.
- Gas-fired power plants marked: Indeck Yerkes Energy Center.
- Metro counties outlined (2): Erie County; Niagara County.
- Cities and towns labeled include: Buffalo; Niagara Falls; North Tonawanda; Lockport.
- Other gas pipelines in the area are drawn in gray and are not labeled.
- Highways are drawn for orientation. A small state locator map sits in a corner.
National Fuel's May 2026 annual report tables, for its whole system, set total Reference Case capacity by source against design day demand with shrinkage.1
| Fiscal year | Total capacity (Dth/day) | Design day demand with shrinkage (Dth/day) | Difference by our subtraction (Dth/day) | Difference as share of demand |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FY 2027 | 1,019,457 | 989,203 | 30,254 | 3.06% |
| FY 2028 | 1,019,360 | 989,247 | 30,113 | 3.04% |
| FY 2029 | 1,019,098 | 988,864 | 30,234 | 3.06% |
National Fuel's Reference Case total capacity and design day demand with shrinkage, whole system. The last two columns are our subtraction and division. Source: NFGDC Long-Term Plan Annual Report, May 2026, Figures III-4 and III-6.12
The filing prints the two series but not their difference, and it states that ample firm capacity is available; the capacity total includes 153,982 Dth/day of large industrial delivered supplies and 54,805 Dth/day of ESCO-provided capacity in FY 2027.1 The record we reviewed shows no scheduled capacity addition.
What is driving new natural gas demand?
National Fuel's printed design day demand is flat through FY 2029, so the record we reviewed shows no growth driver and no new large load with a service date.1
EIA's September 2026 generator inventory lists no planned natural gas-fired generator there, the New York Independent System Operator (NYISO) queue of September 30, 2026 has no natural gas entry in either county.67 Our Federal Register search since January 1, 2025 found three FERC notices that name Erie County and none that names Niagara County, all on National Fuel Gas Supply Corporation storage-well and pipeline work and none tied to a gas load.19
EIA does list existing gas-fired plants in the two counties, such as the Indeck Yerkes Energy Center in Erie County (40.6 MW, in service December 1989); they are electric generators and add no planned gas load.12
Data centers: As of October 29, 2026, we found no filing showing a data center gas load in Erie or Niagara County, whether on National Fuel's system or served directly by a pipeline.11 NYISO's load list does have 8 data center entries in the two counties, with 2,016 MW of requested peak electric load in total; these are electric loads, and the queue does not say whether natural gas serves any of them.7
Nearby: National Fuel Gas Supply's May 2026 customer presentation lists serving directly connected power generation among projects in early-stage development, naming no plant, county or service date, and says construction has commenced on the Tioga Pathway project (190,000 Dth per day) in Tioga County, outside the metro; the presentation gives it for the pipeline company, not for the metro alone.8
What should Buffalo-area facilities check now?
- Tariffs and charges, through a utility audit. Confirm each account is on the right rate class and tariff, and that riders, demand charges and capacity-related charges are billed correctly. Over 70% of the clients Discovery Energy has audited were billed incorrectly. An audit verifies tariffs and charges and recovers overcharges before winter costs rise.
- Sales or transportation service. Confirm whether each site buys gas from National Fuel or through a supplier, since National Fuel named the capacity needed if transportation customers convert to sales service as a risk factor.
- Firm or interruptible, and the terms. Know the interruption terms in the tariff for each account; this page does not state them because the filings we reviewed do not include the tariff.
- Backup plans and fuel. Check that alternate-fuel and curtailment plans are current and feasible, and that fuel inventories and resupply arrangements are in place before December.
- Upcoming reports. Track National Fuel's next annual long-term plan report, expected around May 2027, and its next long-term plan, due December 15, 2026 unless the Commission grants National Fuel's request to move it to April 1, 2027.10
What to check in your contracts
| Area | What to check |
|---|---|
| Winter price spikes | Whether the gas is priced on a daily or a monthly index, how large the local basis (the gap between the local price and the national benchmark) has been in cold weather, and how much of your winter use is covered by fixed-price volumes. |
| Delivery constraints | Whether your transportation is firm, what delivery obligations your supplier carries and what happens if it cannot deliver, and what the curtailment provisions say about who is cut first. |
| Operational flow orders | What balancing obligations the contract places on you, and whether penalties that a pipeline or utility charges under an operational flow order are passed through to you. |
| Expansion plans | Where a utility or pipeline plans added capacity, whether the utility has confirmed in writing the incremental hourly and daily capacity available to your site, and from what date. |
Checks for gas supply and transportation contracts. They are questions to put to your supplier or utility, not financial advice.
Winter and market context
NOAA's Climate Prediction Center said on October 15, 2026 that its November 2026 to January 2027 outlook gives the highest odds of warmer than normal conditions to, among other areas, the Great Lakes and interior Northeast, a discussion that names regions and not New York counties.B1 National EIA and NOAA figures that do not bear on National Fuel's system are in a note.16
The pipeline filings we found since August 2026 for National Fuel Gas Supply and Empire Pipeline are rate and standards filings and two requests to abandon storage wells in Pennsylvania, and none names a county in the metro or a new gas load.17 Either pipeline's own informational postings are not covered here, so we do not know of any operating notices.
Winter weather and NOAA's outlook
Heating degree days, a measure of how much heating the weather called for, ran below the 1991-2020 normal in the winters of 2023-24 and 2024-25 and above it in 2025-26 at the Buffalo Niagara International Airport station.13 NOAA's Climate Prediction Center outlook issued October 15, 2026 gives the Buffalo area at least a 50% chance of above-normal temperatures for November 2026 to January 2027 and for December 2026 to February 2027.14 The airport is one station standing in for the metro, and NOAA's figures are probabilities for a three-month average, not a forecast of specific days.15
| Winter (November to March) | Heating degree days | 1991-2020 normal | Difference from normal |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023-24 | 4225 | 5024 | -15.9% |
| 2024-25 | 4679 | 5024 | -6.9% |
| 2025-26 | 5187 | 5024 | +3.2% |
Heating degree days at the Buffalo Niagara International Airport station, base 65 degrees F, against the 1991-2020 normal. Source: NOAA Regional Climate Centers.
What's new (as of October 29, 2026)
On July 30 and September 4, 2026 National Fuel Gas Supply Corporation asked FERC to abandon two injection and withdrawal storage wells in Pennsylvania, citing localized defects in one and localized corrosion in the other; the notices do not say whether National Fuel's New York system uses them.9 NYISO's September 30, 2026 queue lists 8 data center load entries in Erie and Niagara counties, which are electric loads.18
Frequently asked questions
Will Buffalo businesses face natural gas shortages this winter?
The record does not show a shortage, and this page makes no prediction about outages. See 'How much spare gas capacity does Buffalo have on the coldest day?'
Is there spare gas capacity in the Buffalo area on the coldest day?
National Fuel's own tables put whole-system capacity above design day demand by a margin below the 5% threshold. That is a utility table, not a Commission finding, and not the metro alone. See 'How much spare gas capacity does Buffalo have on the coldest day?'
Does National Fuel have areas where gas may not be delivered reliably?
National Fuel reported in its long-term plan that it did not have any vulnerable locations. The consultant to Staff said in 2023 that modeling revealed low pressures in isolated pockets, without locating them. See 'Key takeaways.'
Could the Buffalo area face a moratorium on new gas connections?
National Fuel said in its May 2026 report that it does not anticipate needing to propose a moratorium on new connections during the plan period. See 'Key takeaways.'
Is a data center driving gas demand in Buffalo?
The record we reviewed does not show one. We found no planned gas-fired generator or pipeline project in Erie or Niagara county, and the NYISO queue's 8 data center entries are electric loads. See 'What is driving new natural gas demand?'
Related case studies
Discovery Energy publishes gas capacity case studies for other metros, using the same method and outlook scale.
- Albany natural gas capacity case study (outlook: Elevated)
- Rochester natural gas capacity case study (outlook: Elevated)
- New York City and Westchester natural gas capacity case study (outlook: Elevated)
- Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island and Long Island natural gas capacity case study (outlook: Elevated)
- Northern New Jersey natural gas capacity case study (outlook: Elevated)
All gas capacity ratings by U.S. metro
Background for commercial and industrial energy buyers: Utility cost intelligence
Understand your capacity exposure
Discovery Energy reviews service elections, interruption terms and regulatory proceedings for organizations across the U.S. and Canada, so capacity changes are understood before they reach the bill.
Schedule a reviewWhat this page does not cover
- Whether pipeline supply to Buffalo has been disrupted since 2020. The records we reviewed show no supply event, but the federal pipeline safety agency's own enforcement records are not covered here.
- Planned capacity additions, how costs are shared among customer groups, and the order in which service would be cut in a shortage. The records we reviewed do not give these for National Fuel.
- Which other gas utilities serve Erie and Niagara counties, and where the low-pressure pockets are.
- Whether any new large gas load appears only in state air permits, federal pipeline filings, utilities' large-load request lists or county economic development filings. Those records are not covered here.
Notes
- National Fuel Gas Distribution Corporation, Long-Term Plan Annual Report, Case 22-G-0610, filed May 29, 2026: Figure III-4 (design day demand with shrinkage, PDF 13) and Figure III-6 (capacity by source, PDF 15). Utility statements. ↩
- Same figures. Difference and share: 30,254 Dth/day and 3.06% for FY 2027; 30,113 and 3.04% for FY 2028; 30,234 and 3.06% for FY 2029. These are our calculation (illustrative); the filing prints the totals, not the difference. ↩
- Same report, PDF 15 and 16 (Gas System Planning Update); the statement on ESCO capacity is on PDF 17. ↩
- CRA Final Report to DPS Staff (July 25, 2023), PDF 6 (hydraulic modeling); Commission Order Implementing Long-Term Natural Gas Plan with Modifications (December 2023), PDF 27 (design day). ↩
- Final Long-Term Plan Appendices D to K (July 17, 2023), Appendix H residential market study, PDF 111 and 234. The metro counties are Erie and Niagara, from the OMB Bulletin No. 23-01 delineation; the match of utility to counties comes from the communities named in the plan. ↩
- EIA-860M inventory for September 2026 (Planned sheet, operator-reported planned dates), filtered to Erie and Niagara counties by us, and a Federal Register search of FERC notices since January 1, 2025 by county phrase, both our own calculation. A notice that spells a place differently would be missed. ↩
- New York Independent System Operator, Interconnection Queue (September 30, 2026), Interconnection Queue, Cluster Projects and Load Projects sheets, filtered by county by us. The data center entries are electric loads. ↩
- National Fuel Gas Supply Corporation and Empire Pipeline, Biennial Customer Meeting presentation, May 21, 2026, page 5; a company presentation about its pipeline business, accessed October 25, 2026. ↩
- Federal Register, FERC notices of requests under National Fuel Gas Supply Corporation's blanket certificate (Docket CP83-4-000): document 2026-16236 (published August 10, 2026, page 51483), Docket CP26-559-000, filed July 30, 2026, to abandon injection/withdrawal Well WH61 in the Wharton Storage Field, Potter County; the notice says the well "contains localized defects and provides negligible injection and withdrawal services." Document 2026-19066 (published September 17, 2026, page 58894), Docket CP26-575-000, filed September 4, 2026, to plug and abandon injection/withdrawal Well 4930 in the Henderson Storage Field, Mercer County, because of "localized corrosion." Both notices were accessed October 29, 2026. Neither says whether National Fuel's distribution system uses the field, and neither states a withdrawal cap. ↩
- National Fuel Gas Distribution Corporation, letter to the Secretary of the New York Public Service Commission, Case 22-G-0610, April 14, 2026 (one page, paragraph 2), requesting an extension of the December 15, 2026 filing date for its next initial long-term plan to April 1, 2027, citing recent changes to Public Service Law section 31 and expected Department guidance; the December 15, 2026 date is in the Commission's December 14, 2023 order (PDF 24). We did not find a response from the Secretary. ↩
- Evidence for the data center statement: EIA-860M (September 2026) Planned sheet, which lists no gas-fired unit in Erie or Niagara County; a Federal Register search of FERC notices published July 31 to October 29, 2026 for Erie County, Niagara County and Buffalo, which returned none; and the NYISO queue read in note 7. State air permit records and the pipelines' own postings could not be reviewed. ↩
- U.S. Energy Information Administration, EIA-860M Preliminary Monthly Electric Generator Inventory, September 2026, Operating sheet (Indeck Yerkes Energy Center, Erie County, plant ID 50451: natural gas combined cycle, 40.6 MW combustion turbine, in service December 1989). The Planned sheet lists no planned gas unit in Erie or Niagara County, and the Retired sheet lists none retired since 2024. ↩
- NOAA Regional Climate Centers, Applied Climate Information System (ACIS) StnData web service, monthly heating degree days (base 65 degrees F) and 1991-2020 normals, November to March of winters 2023-24 to 2025-26, accessed October 29, 2026: Buffalo Niagara International Airport (station USW00014733). Sums are our calculation. Heating degree days behind the percentages: 4225 in 2023-24, 4679 in 2024-25 and 5187 in 2025-26, against a 1991-2020 normal of 5024. ↩
- NOAA Climate Prediction Center, seasonal temperature outlook issued October 15, 2026 (shapefiles from ftp.cpc.ncep.noaa.gov/GIS/us_tempprcpfcst/seastemp_202610.zip), read at the Buffalo location. The map gives the favored category and the lower edge of its probability band; NOAA's explanation keeps near-normal at 33.3% and gives the opposite category the rest, so for both periods Buffalo has at least a 50% chance of above-normal temperatures, about 33% near-normal and no more than 17% below-normal. ↩
- The station is Buffalo Niagara International Airport; one airport station is not a measurement of the whole metro. The outlook figures are NOAA's probabilities for a three-month average and do not rule out cold days. ↩
- EIA said on October 6, 2026 that it expects U.S. natural gas inventories to enter the winter heating season 2% above the previous five-year average, and its October 2026 Short-Term Energy Outlook says prolonged periods of cold weather could increase withdrawals beyond its forecast (sources A1 and A2). EIA lists U.S. liquefied natural gas gross exports of 15 billion cubic feet per day in 2025, 18 in 2026 and 19 in 2027. NOAA's Climate Prediction Center puts the probability of at least a strong El Nino continuing through January to March 2027 at 80%. These are national and regional facts, not statements about National Fuel's system. ↩
- Federal Register, FERC notices published July 31 to October 29, 2026 found by a search for "National Fuel Gas Supply" and "Empire Pipeline" (the searches for Erie County, Niagara County and Buffalo returned none): documents 2026-16236 and 2026-19066 (the two well abandonment requests in note 9), 2026-19575 (September 24, 2026; a National Fuel Gas Supply rate filing, docket RP26-1262), 2026-19068 (September 17, 2026; an Empire Pipeline negotiated rate filing, docket RP26-1252) and 2026-17633 (August 28, 2026; National Fuel and Empire standards compliance filings, dockets RP26-1074 and RP26-1075). ↩
- Same New York Independent System Operator queue (September 30, 2026) as note 7: 8 data center entries in Erie and Niagara counties, 2,016 MW of requested peak electric load in total. ↩
- Federal Register, Federal Energy Regulatory Commission notices that name Erie County, New York, found by our search of notices since January 1, 2025 for county names in the singular and the plural; we saved the text of each notice. (a) National Fuel Gas Supply Corporation; Notice of Request Under Blanket Authorization and Establishing Intervention and Protest Deadline, document 2025-01863, published January 29, 2025, 90 FR 8394 to 8396 (docket CP25-43-000): National Fuel Gas Supply's request of January 3, 2025 to plug and abandon two injection/withdrawal wells and their well lines in the Colden Storage Field, Erie County; the company says the wells provide poor deliverability and that the project will not result in abandonment or a decrease in service to its customers. (b) National Fuel Gas Supply Corporation; Notice of Request for Extension of Time, document 2025-15147, published August 11, 2025, 90 FR 38645 (docket CP24-479-001): National Fuel Gas Supply's request of July 28, 2025 for an extension of time, until August 24, 2026, to complete the Zoar Storage Field Project in Erie County (abandonment of storage wells; the company reports a small annular vent found at two wells already abandoned and asks for time to remediate the vents, finish abandonment and restore the well sites). (c) National Fuel Gas Corporation; Notice of Request Under Blanket Authorization and Establishing Intervention and Protest Deadline, document 2025-23945, published December 30, 2025, 90 FR 61140 to 61141 (docket CP26-41-000): National Fuel Gas Supply's request of December 12, 2025 to replace about 2.86 miles of 16-inch Line C46S pipeline and modernize two metering and regulating stations in Erie County (Line C46S 2026 Modernization Project), to modernize older sections of its system. None names a gas load or National Fuel's distribution utility or says whether the distribution system uses the Colden or Zoar fields, and none states a withdrawal cap; we did not read the filings themselves. The Federal Register lists document 2025-23945 under the heading National Fuel Gas Corporation, but its text names National Fuel Gas Supply Corporation. ↩
Market and weather sources
Public web sources, as of October 25, 2026. They are context, separate from the regulatory record cited in the Notes. The Climate Prediction Center issues its seasonal outlook once each month near mid-month; this section is refreshed on the publication date.
- A1. U.S. Energy Information Administration, press release, "EIA expects a mixed picture for winter fuel costs this year," October 6, 2026. Link
- A2. U.S. Energy Information Administration, Short-Term Energy Outlook, October 2026 (natural gas storage). Link
- B1. NOAA Climate Prediction Center, Prognostic Discussion for Long-Lead Seasonal Outlooks, issued October 15, 2026. Link ↩
Sources
- New York State Department of Public Service, Case 22-G-0610, National Fuel Gas Distribution Corporation Long-Term Plan Annual Report (May 29, 2026). Link
- New York State Department of Public Service, Case 22-G-0610, CRA Final Report. Link
- National Fuel, Final Long-Term Plan Appendices D to K, Case 22-G-0610. Link
- National Fuel, Order Implementing Long-Term Natural Gas Plan with Modifications, Case 22-G-0610. Link
- Office of Management and Budget, OMB Bulletin No. 23-01, Revised Delineations of Metropolitan Statistical Areas, Micropolitan Statistical Areas, and Combined Statistical Areas, July 21, 2023.
- U.S. Energy Information Administration, EIA-860M Preliminary Monthly Electric Generator Inventory, September 2026. Link
- Federal Register, API search of Federal Energy Regulatory Commission notices by county. Link
- New York Independent System Operator, Interconnection Queue, September 30, 2026. Link
- National Fuel Gas Supply Corporation and Empire Pipeline, Biennial Customer Meeting presentation, May 2026. Link
- Federal Register (FERC notice), National Fuel Gas Supply Corporation; Notice of Request Under Blanket Authorization, Docket CP26-559-000, document 2026-16236, published August 10, 2026. Link
- Federal Register (FERC notice), National Fuel Gas Supply Corporation; Notice of Request Under Blanket Authorization, Docket CP26-575-000, document 2026-19066, published September 17, 2026. Link
- Federal Register (FERC Combined Notice of Filings), Combined Notice of Filings, document 2026-19575, published September 24, 2026 (read, not used on the page). Link
- Federal Register (FERC Combined Notice of Filings), Combined Notice of Filings, document 2026-19068, published September 17, 2026 (read, not used on the page). Link
- Federal Register (FERC Combined Notice of Filings), Combined Notice of Filings, document 2026-17633, published August 28, 2026 (read, not used on the page). Link
- New York State Public Service Commission (filing by National Fuel Gas Distribution Corporation), Letter to the Secretary, Case 22-G-0610, April 14, 2026, requesting an extension of the long-term plan filing date. Link
- NOAA Regional Climate Centers (ACIS web service), Monthly heating degree days base 65F and 1991-2020 normals, station USW00014733. Link
- Federal Register (FERC notice), National Fuel Gas Supply Corporation; Notice of Request Under Blanket Authorization and Establishing Intervention and Protest Deadline (FR 2025-01863, January 29, 2025). Link
- Federal Register (FERC notice), National Fuel Gas Supply Corporation; Notice of Request for Extension of Time (FR 2025-15147, August 11, 2025). Link
- Federal Register (FERC notice), National Fuel Gas Corporation; Notice of Request Under Blanket Authorization and Establishing Intervention and Protest Deadline (FR 2025-23945, December 30, 2025). Link